November 16, 2006
You can't win over stupidity by using logic.

In today's Seattle Times letters to the editor page, I found the following:

Yes, there's a lot of grousing about taxes. The Democrats are going to tax the heck out of Republicans. It's all so unfair. Just think how awful it would be if our wealthier citizens had to pay the same proportion of their income in taxes as the middle class [pays of its]. Horrors!

-- Jim White, Lake Forest Park

How do you have a rational debate about tax policy with people who don't seem to have a clue about how our tax system works.

Proportion can be defined as: the quotient obtained when the magnitude of a part is divided by the magnitude of the whole, or the amount of tax one pays divided by one's income, which gives a ratio, or percentage. In the US, we have a "progressive" income tax system that takes a higher percent (proportion) of ones income in taxes the more that individual earns. By definition that means that the wealthy pay a higher proportion of thier income, as well as more in actual dollars than those in lower income brackets.

It is Orwellian, that a principle of the democrats is absolutely untrue on it's face. A statement is not factual merely because it's a widely held belief, and in this case the lie is also destructive, it creates a political climate of envy, where democrat tax policy is not based on egalitarian principles, but on the socialist value that it is acceptable to take more from some because they have earned more than others.

Now I can debate the merits of a progressive tax system with liberals all day, but only if we can all start with the truth. The truth...Horrors!

Posted by dcovey54 at November 16, 2006 08:51 AM | Email This
Comments
1. Yep, that's why they call themselves "Progressives."

They admire taking more from the rich. It never occurs to them that by taking money from those most likely to reinvest in capital and wealth creation, it hurts the economy, and thus those in the lower brackets they purport to help.

It's a short term strategy, which is what Progressives are all about. Don't think ahead, just do what's in the interest of expediency.

The whole point is that they couldn't implement Marxism using the traditional methods of communism or socialism because they are economically infeasible. So today we have the new classist warfare or soft cultural Marxism. That translates to: Let capitalists and those who want to work hard do so to create wealth. Then vilify them and take their wealth for redistribution.

But it's so true. When you've got dolts like Jim White here in the Puget Sound who don't even know which way is up, it's pretty hard to explain rational economics.

Posted by: Jeff B. on November 16, 2006 09:05 AM
Post a comment
Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember info?