June 22, 2009
Cliff Mass And Company Go To Court

Here's the story, in brief.

Seattle Public Schools' choice of new high-school math textbooks has been challenged by three people who say the books' approach is failing many students.

The Seattle School Board recently approved the purchase of three books published by Key Curriculum Press: "Discovering Algebra," "Discovering Geometry" and "Discovering Advanced Algebra."

The vote was 4-3, with three board members expressing concern about whether the books were too heavily weighted toward one side of the often-contentious debate over how best to teach math.

The appeal was filed in King County Superior Court by parent DaZanne Porter, retired math teacher Martha McLaren and Cliff Mass, University of Washington professor of atmospheric science.

(I hope to get more information for you on the appeal, and other possible moves, directly from the source.)

Since I am not a lawyer, I will not try to guess whether this appeal will succeed.  But I will add that the school board may change its mind after the next election, especially since one of those in the majority, Cheryl Chow, is not running for re-election.

(If you want some background on the controversy, you might want to start with Professor Mass's op-ed.)

Posted by Jim Miller at June 22, 2009 09:28 AM | Email This
Comments
1. This would be a great trial to attend as a spectator, if my evil secret committee of the Ruling Proletariat would just cough up a daily stipend sufficient to cover limousine expenses.

A cross-examination of a school board member by a non-innumerate lawyer would be a glorious highlight.

Please keep us quivering citizens up to date on Court proceedings.

Posted by: Insufficiently Sensitive on June 22, 2009 01:28 PM
2. Hey guys the law says a school board can pick text books and if you don't like it vote them out. This would appear to be one of those frivolous lawsuits, and an invitation to an "activist" judge to impose her "policy judgments" for those of the elected officials. We have to condemn this kind of lawsuit as improper and as conservatives are firmly on record on these points, I am sure you wil alljoin me in condemning this suit, and hoping the judge throws it out right away.
There's also a little matter of standing....I'm not clear on how being a weatherman makes you have standing for this suit.

That doctrine btw is perhaps THE major limitation on power of judges....they only can decide a real case brought by someone with a real stake in it, they can't just roam around and decide anything.

So, Insufficiently Sensitive, and others, I ask you to join in hoping the judge throws out this suit right away.

(Btw I personally support old math ... I do believe Pythagoras would, too, and that's really old math! Canyou imagine a shop class asking kids to invent a table saw, or fire? A history class asking students to research and write their own textbook? The store of learning has great value.)

Posted by: Torture Lawyer on June 22, 2009 06:56 PM
3. And there's more. It's actually a race discrimination lawsuit where Mass is alleging that a state constitutional provision against discrimination is being vioalted because the new math text books leave non caucasian students farther behind.

In other words, Mass' position in this suit is that something that on its face isn't racist, can be shown to be racist if it produces differential results.

Just like the city of New Haven in the fire fighters case!

So now I am triply sure all conservatives will join in decrying this lawsuit as being frivolous and a typical example of lawsuit abuse.

that is, the principled ones.

Posted by: Yup Torture Lawyer again on June 22, 2009 07:28 PM
4. While I love Cliff's weather blog, he is doing a few things that should bother small government conservatives;
a) using whacko race laws to snare the school board (morons)
b) lobby for Fed $$ for better weather radar.

while i sympathize with both, i wonder what Barry Goldwater would say?

Posted by: righton on June 22, 2009 07:48 PM
5. Hi, kingcountyyr.org to GoogleReader!
Tania

Posted by: Tania on June 22, 2009 09:51 PM
6. Results consistenly show that Singapore math works, yet Seattle is determined to watch kids fail with Constructivist math. Let Seattlelites and their kids get what they deserve as long as they keep voting for Progressives.

Posted by: Jeff B. on June 23, 2009 07:16 AM
7.
It absolutely agree with the previous phrase

Posted by: LeraJenkins on June 25, 2009 10:12 PM
Post a comment
Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember info?