December 20, 2007
The Worst Christmas Songs Ever (And Some of My Favorite) Update

With Christmas now just five days away Americans on the whole have probably been bombarded with hundreds of holiday songs. You can probably get a grant from the federal government to do a study on this. Call your congressman now.

Admittedly many of the songs are classics (Little Drummer Boy, Good King Wenceslaus, Walking in a Winter Wonderland) and some are even musical masterpieces; Handel's "Messiah".

But more often than not you get some bad cover performed by a soon-to-be washed-up rock or country singer trying to squeeze a few extra shekels out of their fans. Or you have your up-and-coming pop act beating the one-hit-wonder horse for every thing they've got.

Like an acoustic water-boarding these songs are played over and over by thoughtless program managers at radio stations, as muzak in department stores and supermarkets and by the annoyingly festive co-worker at your office.

Exhaustive research has gone into the production of this list. Initially my goal was simply to share some of my favorite songs. Knowing my sense of humor and my notorious taste in music Sound Politics readers can probably guess their quality.

With education ultimately leading to legislative and legal action hopefully next Christmas can be made more jolly by having the worst of these offenders forever removed from American culture.

If by chance I missed any tunes, be kind enough to share. Or if you're even nicer, don't.

The Worst

"Christmas in the Northwest" Brenda Kutz White (1985)

I have a great deal of nostalgia for "Christmas in the Northwest". At White Center Heights Elementary I seem to recall being herded into the gym every December to listen to it as part of our school holiday concert. The asbestos particulates from the heating system wasn't all that was harmful floating in the air.

For two decades we've been forced to hear this song for every telethon and fundraiser that's held even remotely close Christmas. After two decades, locals have taken it kind of hard. A friend of mine, who is a sixth generation Washingtonian, said it drives her nuts every time she hears it. I almost got in a fight with my mom once when I joked about her liking it. It's no laughing matter when you consider that Seasonal Affective Disorder was first diagnosed around the same time Brenda White recorded this song. I don't believe in coincidences.

"Penguin, James Penguin" - Brad Paisley (2006)
Paisley has done the oddest collection of country songs since Tom T. Hall. And that can be taken as a complement by some folks.

"Last Christmas" Wham! (1984)
Incredibly there are people using their real names online saying this is their favorite Christmas song ever. Who knew George Michael touched so many people that way?

"Happy Christmas (War is Over)" - John Lennon & The Plastic Ono Band (1972)
Another self-promotional piece of tripe from John Lennon's solo career. He was never about ending the Vietnam War. He was about John Lennon wanting to end the Vietnam War. And then there's Yoko Ono playing lead banshee by screeching during the chorus.

"Blue Christmas" - Elvis Presley (1957)
Sung by the future namesake of King County.

"Christmas at Ground Zero" - Weird Al Yankovic (1986)
All of your Christmases will be white during nuclear winter.

"Rock and Roll Christmas" - George Thorogood (1983)
Apparently during the holidays, Lonesome George doesn't drink alone.

"Merry Christmas (I Don't Want to Fight Tonight)" - The Ramones (1987)
Punk may be dead. And Joey, Johnny and Dee Dee might be in the grave too. And, ummm, not sure where I was going with this...

"Have a Cheeky Christmas" - The Cheeky Girls (2003)
How can a Christmas carol sung by a pair of scantily clad Rumanian twins measuring 34-24-34 be bad? You be the judge.

"Do They Know It's Christmas" - Band Aid (1984)
If you can feed and clothe a child for a month on just what you spend on the price of a cup of coffee, I've always wondered how many tons of flour and rice could have been bought from money blown by Band Aid participants on heroin, cocaine, cars, private jets, mansions, male prostitutes, hookers, parties and lawsuits. Of course with the financial straits that many of these musicians must now be in, maybe a Band Aid to raise money for ex-Band Aid participants is in order.

"Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas" - Kenny G. (1997)
I always smile when I listen to folks who moved up here in the 1990s talk about how great the music was in Seattle. I've got one and a half words for ya. Kenny G.

"Thank God It's Christmas" - Queen (1984)

"Falling Leaves" - John Denver (1987)
One does have to miss John Denver's appearances on TV during Christmas specials, on the Muppets and on the news fighting off domestic violence charges. Incidentally, if anyone reading this ever happens to become a famous actor or musician, never, never, ever fly in single engine airplane. Especially if its one you built by yourself.

"Step into Christmas" - Elton John (1974)
A very appropriate title given this post's topic.

"My Only Wish" - Britney Spears (2000)
Maybe she can wish for an effective oral contraceptive next year.

"Christmas in Dallas" - The 1986 Dallas Cowboys (1986)
Unless you were born in Texas there is no reason ever to root for the Cowboys. And through the decades there are too many reasons for real football fans to hate "America's Team". Add "Christmas in Dallas" to the list.

"12 Days of Christmas" - Jeff Foxworthy (2000)
You might be a redneck if you've heard this twist to the old standby. Personally, you're just not right if some of the gifts mentioned don't apply to you. Parts to a Mustang GT? This guy right here. *raises hand*

"Wonderful Christmas Time" - Paul McCartney (1979)
Seattle Weekly editor Mike Seely calls this the most brutal Christmas song ever made. Hard to argue. Of course he's a fan of Band Aid's aforementioned ditty so go figure.

"Christmas Shoes" - Newsong (2000)
This song's premise is about a little boy waiting in line to buy a pair of shoes for his dying mother but he doesn't have enough scratch so he hits up a stranger to pick up the tab. A nice little scam if ever there was one. I had never heard of this tune until my buddy brought it up. Now I'm wishing he hadn't. After being released by a Christian vocal group "Christmas Shoes" spawned a children's book and movie. Of course the listeners aren't supposed to wonder why the kid is blowing cash on shoes. Gotta agree with my friend when he says "How about you get her a kidney you little brat?"

"Hard Candy Christmas" - Dolly Parton (1982)
Nothing says wholesome family values like a song from Best Little Whorehouse in Texas.

"Christmas Through Your Eyes" - Gloria Estefan (1993)
Try to resist putting a candy cane through your eyes...and ears.

"Father Christmas" The Kinks (1977)
When you've made a classic about a man falling in love with a cross-dresser why would would a talented group like the Kinks feel the need to do a Christmas song?

"Let it be Christmas" - Alan Jackson (2002)
And let Alan Jackson sing songs once again that don't profit from Christmas, exploit terrorism or cover tunes once sung by more talented musicians.

"Hey Santa!" - Carnie and Wendy Wilson (1993)
Obviously the apples fell pretty far from this tree.

"Breath of Heaven (Mary's Song)" - Amy Grant (1992)

"A Christmas to Remember" - Kenny Rogers & Dolly Parton (1984)
There used to be a day when people only had five television stations and they were made to watch Christmas specials on the tube every December. Yes I was forced to watch Kenny and Dolly's superb performance on our old Zenith as a kid. I try not to talk about it much.

"Santa Claus is Coming to Town" - Dokken (2007)

"Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas" - Twisted Sister (2006)

Both of the above songs can be found on Christmas Monster Ballads now out on CD and featuring tracks from Queensryche, Billy Idol, Skid Row and other Metal favorites. If ever there was a way to show someone how you really felt about them, stuffing some bitchin Xmas guitar licks into their stocking will do the trick.

"Christmas (Baby Please Come Home)" - U2 (1987)

"Some Day at Christmas (There'll be no war)" - Stevie Wonder (1967)
Until then we'll have to keep dropping laser guided sub-munitions on throat-cutters seeking to create a new Caliphate.

"Santa Baby" - RuPaul (1997)
Someone actually thought producing a RuPaul Christmas album was a good idea.

"Celebrate Me Home" - Kenny Loggins (1977)

"Christmas in Dixie" - Alabama (1982)
If you're gonna sing on Christmas, you gotta have a fiddle in the band.

"It's Christmas All Over the World" - Sheena Easton (1987)
From the Santa Claus: The Movie starring Dudley Moore.

"Merry Christmas Santa Claus" - Max Headroom (1986)
That Columbian gold that the CIA was peddling in the 1980s; I don't know what chemical they were lacing it with but it certainly produced some interesting results.

Extra: Oh, and to show I'm not a Grinch, here are four of my favorite modern Christmas songs that I came across.

"I am Santa Claus" - Bob Rivers Twisted Radio (1993)
Bob Rivers is a local icon almost of the same importance as "Almost Live" or Chubby and Tubby. To be fair this song shouldn't be in this bad Christmas song discussion unless you're talking about it being the most bad-ass Christmas carol ever. Rivers has done some other admirable Christmas parodies, "Aquaclaus", "Jingle Hells Bells" and "Merry Christmas Allah". They don't top "I am Santa Claus".

"Happy Birthday Jesus" - R. Lee Ermey (1987)
Probably the most touching musical refrain ever.

"Christmas With the Devil" - Spinal Tap (1984)

"Christmas Is All Around" - Billy Mack (2003)
OK, I don't want anyone giving me guff about paying money to see a Hugh Grant movie at the theaters. And buying the CD. And watching it on cable. Multiple times. There's a good reason. Well, a couple good reasons.

Results: Personally, my vote for worst Christmas song is either "Cheeky Christmas" or "Last Christmas" by Wham!

Naughty and nice: Arwen correctly points out that I didn't put "Grandma Got Runover By a Reindeer". This is because I was testing the readers. Yeah, that's the ticket. Arwen, your Soundpolitics No-Prize is in the mail.

I think I'm forced to give out TheTim's IP address so people can track him down to thank him personally for his contribution.

Thanks to Mike Seely. It wouldn't be a Sound Politics Christmas Special without a celebrity guest appearance.

Ralph N. points out "Christmas at Denny's" by Randy Stonehill. Perhaps.

I'm more fond of the cover performed by our very own Chris Nandor, aka, Pudge.
If this version of "Christmas at Denny's" doesn't hit Double Myrrh then there isn't any justice in the world.

Posted by DonWard at December 20, 2007 07:14 AM | Email This
Comments
1. Best Christmas carol ever, O' Holy Night, performed the best ever by Sergio Franco so very many years ago. Powerful voice, powerful stuff.

Posted by: katomar on December 20, 2007 08:23 AM
2. if I hear Burl Ives's Have A Holly Jolly Xmas one more time - I think I'll puke!

Posted by: Elf on December 20, 2007 08:26 AM
3. Your forgot the Northwest version of "Walking in a Winterland", also known as "Latte Land". Right up there with Christmas in the Northwest.
As far as good songs, just give me some classic Bing Crosby "White Christmas".

Posted by: WarmFuzzyPuppies on December 20, 2007 08:30 AM
4. #3: I'm with you WFP; Bing does it for me in the nostalgia category for Xmas's past.

Posted by: Elf on December 20, 2007 08:33 AM
5. I am surprised "Grandma got run over by a reindeer" didn't make the worst list. Oh, how I hate that song.

Posted by: Arwen on December 20, 2007 08:33 AM
6. I've been blissfully free of most holiday music this year. The vast majority of it is total garbage and painful to listen to - the modern stuff is generally the worst.

Posted by: John Galt on December 20, 2007 09:01 AM
7. It is not holiday music, although holiday means Holy Day and that would be Christmas. Problem is Christmas music begins before Thanksgiving as retailers push for a longer season to end the year in the black. I agree that the Grandma got run over is the worst. One of the most beautiful Christmas songs is Mary Did You Know by Kathy Matea or Michael English.

Posted by: WVH on December 20, 2007 09:10 AM
8. I think the worst has to be "It's the Most Wonderful Time of the Year" by Andy Williams. ***Barf***

Posted by: JimmyTheGeek on December 20, 2007 09:15 AM
9. I don't think one can be qualified to declare a winner in the "worst Christmas songs ever" competition until one has listened to this version of O Holy Night.

Seriously.

Posted by: The Tim on December 20, 2007 09:15 AM
10. I think the worst has to be "It's the Most Wonderful Time of the Year" by Andy Williams. It is played WAY too much.

Posted by: JimmyTheGeek on December 20, 2007 09:16 AM
11. Wham's gem on the worst list? Come on, Don, keep an open mind!

Posted by: Seely on December 20, 2007 09:39 AM
12.
Why don't you descend from your mountain top with a big sled and your dog and steal all the Christmas songs from Whoville?

Or better yet, why don't you put that old man in a white beard who works at Macy's in an old age home because you don't believe in him.

Posted by: John Bailo on December 20, 2007 09:47 AM
13. A couple of additional "worsts", mainly due to overplaying:

"We Wish You a Merry Christmas" by the Muppets

"Felice Navidaz" (sp?) by several artist

Posted by: tc on December 20, 2007 09:57 AM
14. The Tim: Thank you for that! :) When he got to the second Fall On Your Knees, I fell off my chair! That is absolutely the worst, but at least he sang it with passion! If we all burst into song a little more, even if we can't sing well, we probably would feel a lot better and be a lot happier.

Posted by: Katomar on December 20, 2007 10:07 AM
15. What a bunch of grinches! ;)

There is not one single Chritmas song I don't like ... I love them all, the beautiful ones that make me weep and the goofy ones that make me groan. They are like our children: celebrations that I love each for their own laudable and quirky qualities.

"Stop the Cavalry" by the Cory Band is an oddity that I love. I heard it on the radio in 1987 when we lived in Pittsburgh, but I never heard the name of the song or the band... it took me 18 years to finally find ...but I listen to it with glee!

Hey, Mr. Churchill comes over here
to say we're doing splendidly
But it's very cold out here in the snow,
marching to and from the enemy
Oh I say it's tough,I have had enough
Can you stop the cavalry?
I have had to fight, almost every night
down throughout these centuries
That is when I say, oh yes yet again
Can you stop the cavalry?
Mary Bradley waits at home
in the nuclear fall-out zone
Wish I could be dancing now
in the arms of the girl I love

[ Chorus ]
Dub a dub a dum dum
Dub a dub a dum
Dub a dum dum dub a dub
Dub a dub a dum
Dub a dub a dum dum
Dub a dub a dum
Dub a dum dum dub a dub
Dub a dub a dum
Wish I was at home for Christmas

Bang! That's another bomb on another town
While the Czar and Jim have tea
If I get home, live to tell the tale
I'll run for all presidencies
If I get elected I'll stop - I
will stop the cavalry

[ Chorus ]

Wish I could be dancing now
in the arms of the girl I love
Mary Bradley waits at home
She has been waiting 2 years long
Wish I was at home for Christmas

***Go Fish song rejects 'Happy Holidays' for less politically correct greeting
It's called Christmas!

Posted by: Ragnar Danneskjold on December 20, 2007 10:27 AM
16. Nothing brings the beauty and spirit of this fine season (or a ceasefire in the War On Xmas) like Tacoman, and Swede-Hindu, Yogi Yorgesson and The Scandahoovians singing "I Yust Go Nuts At Christmas!"


(don't tase me, Don!)

Posted by: blathering michael on December 20, 2007 10:47 AM
17. the worst---"Rockin' Around the Christmas Tree." By far. Followed closely by the McCartney song.

Posted by: Michele on December 20, 2007 11:05 AM
18. A couple of others to add to the list:

"I Won't Be Home for Christmas" by Blink 182
"The Night Santa Went Crazy" by Weird Al
I'm also rapidly beginning to get sick of "Santa Baby" in all it's variations.

Posted by: Brian Lutz on December 20, 2007 11:07 AM
19. Hey! I love "Rockin' Around the Christmas Tree". I remember when it was new back in 1958.

As for the worst, I totally agree. It has to be McCartney's off key "Wonderful Christmas Time". It is played without relief every Christmas and listening to it is even worse than the sound of Hillary's cackling. Well maybe not, but it's close.

My favorites? Certainly the aforementioned Yogi Yorgesson's "I yust go nuts at Christmas". Also Stan Freeberg's "Green Christmas" a tongue-in-cheek late '50's dig at commercialism is a classic.

My true favorites though are rendered by Frank Sinatra, Nat "King" Cole, Dean Martin, and Bing Crosby.

Posted by: Bill Cruchon on December 20, 2007 11:23 AM
20. I have a few Christmas songs that I am not all that partial too but what really sends me through the roof is to go to Mass on Sunday and have to put up with the moronic hootenanny jug band "front stage" that the faithful have been forced to entertain since Vatican II. The people responsible should be spit roasted for giving scandal to the Church.

Can't those who participate in this menace to society get their rocks off at a Karaoke bar, if their problem stems from a need for attention, or by torturing kittens if they are merely sadistic?

Posted by: JDH on December 20, 2007 11:32 AM
21. One of the worst ever that is being played ad nauseum in the stores "Last Christmas I gave you my heart..." by various mediocre artists.

"Go Tell It On The Mountain" and "Jesus Was Born Today" are among my favorites. I enjoy both serious and silly songs. The only reason we have to put up with the aforementioned dirges is that the commericial outlets are too afraid of offending the one obnoxious person who seems to be in every crowd.

Posted by: Burdabee on December 20, 2007 11:37 AM
22. Tim,

That was hilarious! I thought I was going to bust a gut.

Add to the best list "Christmas Time is Here" by the Vince Guarldi Trio (Charlie Brown Christmas) and "Welcome Christmas" from the Grinch.

Posted by: Ken on December 20, 2007 11:40 AM
23. Some of the best---almost any Christmas song rendition by Mannheim Steamroller.

Posted by: Michele on December 20, 2007 11:50 AM
24. 'Have Yourself A Merry Little Christmas' by Rush Limbaugh.

Posted by: Thumper on December 20, 2007 11:55 AM
25. Some of the worst---almost any Christmas song rendition by Mannheim Steamroller. (Sorry Michele)

Tim, my day was going pretty good until I followed your link. Thanks alot! Now I'm going to have that banshee shrieking in my head the rest of the afternoon. Especially after I listen to it three or four more times.

Posted by: deedub on December 20, 2007 12:39 PM
26. For the sports fans, KJR's band Last Call Orchestra does a pretty good rendition of The Twelve Days of Christmas. I never get tired of the fifth day - "Claaayyyy Bennn-Nettt Sucks!"

Posted by: Palouse on December 20, 2007 01:01 PM
27. I agree with Last Christmas as the worst--George Michael is bad enough WITHOUT singing a Christmas song. My two favorites are White Christmas by Bing Crosby and Please Come Home for Christmas
by the Eagles.

Posted by: Bill H on December 20, 2007 01:06 PM
28. Oh, and on the lighter side, here is an a cappella version of 12 Days of Christmas Gone Wrong

Posted by: Bill H on December 20, 2007 01:12 PM
29. As for number 14 on your worst list, Elton John's "Step into Christmas," rumor has it that he is going to reprise the tune this year after an inspirational visit to the Minneapolis airport. Working title: "Tap into Christmas."

Posted by: Ike on December 20, 2007 02:32 PM
30. Ike....GROAN!

Meanwhile...why is it that Silent Night always gets the mortars started in a combat zone?

Posted by: Diogenes on December 20, 2007 03:37 PM
31. So glad I could spread a little cheer today with that song. *evil grin*

Posted by: The Tim on December 20, 2007 03:39 PM
32. Without question, the best Christmas songs/hymns come from the rich Christian tradition that celebrates this holy day. How good they are at the moment depends on the arrangement/performer(s).

The best of the rest must be "White Christmas" by Bing Crosby and "The Christmas Song" by Nat King Cole.

Now for the worst ... I swear that I heard this once, just once, almost 20 years ago. But once was more than enough. (I have a co-worker who heard it at another time in another place, too.)

I don't remember if this is the name, but it's something like "Christmas dinner alone at Denny's." I heard it just a few days before Christmas in a year when things were going well, I was really in the holiday spirit -- and the song almost drove me into Cook Inlet!!

This guy is eating dinner alone at Denny's. It's Christmas day. And he thinks back to another Christmas when he and his wife gave their son a red wagon.

Yep, the kid got killed in his wagon in the street, the wagon turned to rust at the edge of the road, the man to drinking, etc.

I still wonder what sick mind penned that so-called Christmas "song."

Posted by: Ralph N on December 20, 2007 03:48 PM
33. Ralph@32,

"Christmas at Denny's" by Randy Stonehill.

You can hear it on Stonehill's myspace page.

I agree, it's 5+ minutes of bad. Worse than cold grits.

Posted by: Smoley on December 20, 2007 04:17 PM
34. I'm a Jew who just loves Christmas music. Also a musician, and whenever I sing or play Silver Bells, I find tears in my eyes.

Posted by: Carol Kujawa on December 20, 2007 04:39 PM
35. While not a tune, this essay by David Sedaris is certainly one of my favorite Christmas stories.


Posted by: Smoley on December 20, 2007 04:44 PM
36. You could shoot your eye out.

Posted by: Bill Cruchon on December 20, 2007 05:29 PM
37. Again, VERY good BC! You're good at it!

Posted by: Yawn on December 20, 2007 05:47 PM
38. "Mary did you know" performed by Kathy Mattea, on her 1994 album, "Good News".

My all time favorite.

Merry Christmas to all.

Posted by: Independent Voter on December 20, 2007 06:03 PM
39. Don, you've obviously never had to be a page turner for organist during Handel's Messiah, at the age of 15, while the female soloist decides to take an artistic license and sing "Despise-Ed, Reject-Ed" over and over again. That one experience honestly made me question Handel's entire ability as a composer. Lol.

Posted by: Gary on December 20, 2007 06:56 PM
40. Celtic Women Christmas Album DVD as one of the better albums (and the ladies definitely to the look and feel of the music) I bought mine at Freddie's for $16.95 which immensely cheaper than sending a donation to PBS and having to listen their continuous ads as to why we need to support PBS.

Posted by: me on December 20, 2007 07:20 PM
41. "Songs of Angels", Robert Shaw and the Robert Shaw Chamber Singers. Simply the best.

Posted by: ewaggin on December 20, 2007 07:35 PM
42. "River" by Joni Mitchell. It's on the "Blue" album.

It's comin' on Christmas
and they're cuttin' down trees
and puttin' up raindeer
and singin' songs of joy and peace

Oh I wish I had a river
I could skate away on
I wish I had a river so long
I would teach my feet to fly

Sad song, but really good. Some holiday seasons are not happy ones, and this song captures that lonely sadness.

Posted by: Bruce Guthrie on December 20, 2007 07:50 PM
43. Well nothing says Christmas time like the Vince Giraldi Charley Brown Christmas songs. David Benoit does a good job at those too.
However.....This tasty little morsel will cost you about 5 minutes of sheer laughing pleasure and will rocket to the top of all your Christmas favorites. Enjoy
http://www.break.com/index/achmed-sings-christmas-songs.html

Posted by: PC on December 20, 2007 08:14 PM
44. Great job PC,

Although, Achmed sounds eerily similar to Triumph The Wonder Dog.

Posted by: Don Ward on December 20, 2007 09:01 PM
45. Thanks Don

Posted by: PC on December 21, 2007 12:19 PM
46. The BEST Christmas song ever: Silent Night by Manheim Steamroller...blissful and beautiful..
Worst is that stupid "song" by the Chipmunks...blech!

Posted by: betsy on December 21, 2007 07:53 PM
47. Call me sick, but I kind of like some of the South Park Christmas music.
WARNING: Profanity and offensiveness
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sR_XN8TNLhY

Mr Garrison's Merry Christmas
Dreiedel, Dreidel
Etc.

I gotta say stay away from "The Most Offensive Song Ever" sung by Kenny. It is very aptly titled.

Posted by: Thom on December 24, 2007 09:56 AM
48. Hey Don, thanks for the hat tip. :-) I also posted a version of Christmas at Ground Zero. Wait for the first verse to kick in. :-)

Posted by: pudge on December 27, 2007 10:40 PM
Post a comment
Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember info?