November 13, 2007
Worth Reading

Bill Virgin Has his own Plan B for transportation.   Here's the first of his modest proposals:

Disband Sound Transit.  One less duplicative bureaucracy to fund and maintain.  Finish King County's light rail -- since so much money has been sunk into it already, we might as well go ahead and finish the thing, then operate it as a laboratory and concrete example of what not to do next time, should the region ever venture into rail again.  Then turn it over to Metro.  Give the Tacoma light rail segment to Pierce Transit.

You'll want to read the whole thing.  In fact, you may even want to buy a copy of the PI, just for this column.

Posted by Jim Miller at November 13, 2007 12:27 PM | Email This
Comments
1. This is officially one of the best editorials ever written by anyone published by the Times or PI.

Bill is dead on. This should become the "bat" to beat traffic planners with.

Posted by: Chris on November 13, 2007 12:49 PM
2. WOW!!! And that was a PI writer? He must not be part of the cocktail crowd around here.

My hot button was touched on, too- the retrofit, not rebuild or tunnel.

Again, WOW!!

Posted by: swatter on November 13, 2007 12:53 PM
3. Well BRAVO to this column. I too have thought they should simply put bus service where it will be heavily used by even car-lovers like me. As he mentions, the park and ride bus service to Husky stadium makes uber sense. I've used it. It's good and sensible. Not the complete waste of time like I see with empty buses driving around downtown Redmond every day. PUT THE BUSES WHERE PEOPLE ARE MOST GOING. Don't have a route just because one or two people might ride it at 1:00 in the afternoon on a Tuesday et al. That angers taxpayers because they know it's wasting money.
Will the pols listen to such common sense?

Posted by: Michele on November 13, 2007 01:16 PM
4. I dunno... sounds like someone is making too much sense. I don't think it's a wise idea to follow people making sense: they're usually targeted by the Jihadi of whichever insane religion their sanity calls on the carpet.

Posted by: Matthew on November 13, 2007 01:46 PM
5. Bill Virgin is the best columnist in Seattle. His piece on how Boeing went wrong outsourcing its business was spot-on (and written before Mr Bair's defenestration).

http://seattlepi.nwsource.com/virgin/335522_virgin16.html

Posted by: Legast on November 13, 2007 01:49 PM
6. Agree with most statements.

Disagree on 520 replacement.

Omissions: Taxis. Recent news, Seattle may be breaking the taxi license monopoly and rearranging the way taxi drivers are paid -- back to the 1950s when they were "employees".

We only have 750 taxis in Seattle! We need thousands for the whole Puget Sound -- and we need subsidies.

http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/localnews/2004010445_taxicabs12m.html

"A recently approved pilot project will test the idea of having drivers operate as they did in the 1950s, 1960s and early 1970s � as employees with benefits and possibly even union representation � rather than as independent contractors, the way they function now.

For the first time in nearly two decades, the county, which along with the city regulates the local taxi industry, will issue new taxi licenses � little decals, affixed to the back of taxi cabs, by which this immigrant-dominated industry lives and dies."

Posted by: John Bailo on November 13, 2007 02:06 PM
7. I can't argue with most of the ideas, although I disagree on disbanding ST, especially handing the Sounder over to Amtrak. Talk about handing something that is working via a semi-functional entity to an entity that doesn't know how to manage passenger service. It would mean the kiss-of-death to the Sounder. I rather see Burlington Northern run it, which they mostly do know (i.e., the conductors/train engineers are Burlington Northern employees). ST should remain, but change from an appointed agency to an elected board, much like the Port commissions. I also don't have a problem with them running the regional bus service. They do a lot better job than Metro does.

Posted by: tc on November 13, 2007 02:12 PM
8. Give your favorite politician a copy of Randal O'Toole's new book The Best-Laid Plans: How Government Planning Harms Your Quality of Life, Your Pocketbook, and Your Future.

Posted by: John Galt on November 13, 2007 02:32 PM
9. @7 - "I disagree on disbanding ST"

"tc" = totally clueless

Here, I'll prove it.

TC, grab yourself a complete copy of the local law the voters in 1996 approved. You know, the one that authorizes and limits ST's rights. It is called Resolution 75, and as Res. 75 states, a second document (called Sound Move) also is part of the law.

I want to ask you some questions about it, just to prove to everybody that you are, indeed, totally clueless. Sound good?

Posted by: Wishkah on November 13, 2007 02:36 PM
10. Forget light rail. King County is now into light ferries.

King County Council votes to go into the ferry business

Will the madness ever end?

Posted by: Smoley on November 13, 2007 03:40 PM
11. UUGGGGGGHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!

Not only are we getting tax increases to subsidize the island residents' foot ferries, the CLOWNCIL also voted to subsidize every resident who lives in a flood plain by raising taxes on everyone else. BOGUS!!!!

Posted by: Palouse on November 13, 2007 03:54 PM
12. What in the world were those promises Gregoire made about the 9-1/2 cent Gas Tax anyway???
Seems like she has tried repeatedly to "bait-and-switch" things she promised like 520 & Alaskan Way to local government.
Gregoire==Gas Tax Bait-and-Switch!!

Posted by: Mr. Cyncial on November 13, 2007 04:13 PM
13. This foot ferry thing really is ridiculus. At least Reagan Dunn had a clue on this waste of $$. Once again us rural people get to subsidize these pet boondoogles that benefit very few seattle centric people. If I wanted these things I'd live in a urban area closer to seattle.
The new flood non-control district is a joke. The net result of this is less money will be spent on actual flood control and levee repairs than in the past. The majority will be spent on environmental projects, i.e., salmon recovery, habitat restoration, ... I've seen the project list, but haven't found an on-line link to it yet that ties $$ to projects.

Posted by: mvray on November 13, 2007 04:41 PM
14. OT, but maybe some of you in Whatcom or Skagit County would like to know: Dino Rossi will be on KGMI's Bonner and Brooks show from 8 to 9 am on Wednesday, November 14th.

Posted by: Peggy U on November 13, 2007 05:03 PM
15. Hey you all, it gets worse.

The levies will fail!!!!!

So we have another tax increase. O-brother.

Explain this dems. You have controled this state for 30+ plus years, what happened....

care to explain DUFFMAN.

Posted by: Army Medic/Vet on November 13, 2007 05:06 PM
16. Smoley, King County has been into Light Fairies for a long time. All those writers at The Stranger have confused "Water Taxi's" with "Water Sports" and that's what's driving this issue. Once Ron Simms has his first golden shower, this will all go away.

Posted by: Doc-T on November 13, 2007 06:17 PM
17. Virgin was a bit off about wanting employers to move out of downtown Seattle and closer to where their employees live. No matter where you move, some employees will be closer, and some further. And nearly half of downtown employees commute by bus, and many walk or bike, so moving will create even more traffic!

Posted by: Tom on November 13, 2007 06:40 PM
18. Good analysis - but he had better watch out for the liberal elite who may try to out him after reading this editorial that goes against virtually all of their wishes.

ST should be disbanded and split among Metro and Pierce and Snohomish County Transit. A laundry list of road projects need to be built and tolls will likely result on some of them, but that is the price we must pay for user's fee. The cost of construction is ever increasing. There are constructive solutions, and just as I predicted - they would surface after the Prop. 1 dragon was slayed.

Posted by: KS on November 13, 2007 10:07 PM
19. Wishkah:
Such anger and hostility. I am not sure what I stated that demanded such an outburst.

My main points were:
1. Elect the board instead of appointments: Per ST website, the current board is appointed by the county commissioners.
"The county executive in each of the participating counties appoints members from that county. The respective county councils confirm the appointments. By state law, appointments must include an elected city official representing the largest city in the participating county and proportional representation from other cities and unincorporated areas. To help assure coordination between local and regional transit plans, half of the appointments in each county must be elected officials who serve on the local transit agency governing authority."

2. Not turn Sounder over to Amtrak: Amtrak's history of poor management is a lot worse than ST's. It would be the death of the Sounder.

3. Also not turn over the regional bus service: I use both the ST Express buses and Sounder on a daily basis. I also use Metro buses. I would rate Metro way behind the other area's transit systems as far as bus management. I would rate Snohomish's Community Transit as tops, then Sound Transit, then Pierce, then Kitsap Transit, and with Metro being last. Metro drivers are often rude (i.e., they act inconvienced when they have to stop, they cut off other bus drivers, pedestrians, and cars, etc.). The buses (other than the ones that serve Kirkland/Redmond or Bellevue) are poorly maintained. Finally, they don't bother sticking to a schedule, unless they have a supervisor at check points checking up on them. The point of a regional bus system was to provide service across the region, instead of just within an certain service area.

Posted by: tc on November 14, 2007 08:07 AM
20. Bill Virgin's columns are often the only reason to buy the P-I.

Posted by: ram on November 15, 2007 07:05 PM
21. Karla Dana Brown [url=http://usuarios.lycos.es/mallysky/karla-dana-brown.html]Karla Dana Brown[/url] Calvin And Hobbes Stupendous Man [url=http://usuarios.lycos.es/mallysky/calvin-and-hobbes-stupendous-man.html]Calvin And Hobbes Stupendous Man[/url] Luxery Condo Management Company Nyc [url=http://usuarios.lycos.es/mallysky/luxery-condo-management-company-nyc.html]Luxery Condo Management Company Nyc[/url] What Love Is Big Sky Movie [url=http://usuarios.lycos.es/mallysky/what-love-is-big-sky-movie.html]What Love Is Big Sky Movie[/url] Clock Masters Stone Mountain Georgia [url=http://usuarios.lycos.es/mallysky/clock-masters-stone-mountain-georgia.html]Clock Masters Stone Mountain Georgia[/url]

Posted by: Billy on November 16, 2007 04:28 PM
Post a comment
Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember info?