December 12, 2006
Contacts Needed

I haven't said anything about the Sea-Tac holiday tree controversy, though other contributors have.   (Here and here.)  Mostly that's because I already said what I have to say on the general subject last year and early this year, though I may recycle my somewhat idiosyncratic ideas if I get the time.  But I have been thinking hard about another local holiday celebration, and I would like some help so that I can cover it as it should be covered.

That celebration is, of course, the third annual Lenin lighting.  (You can see a socialist realism poster for the event here, if your taste runs to such things.)

To understand my reaction to this event, you should know that I translate politically correct terms automatically as I read, and so when I read that Fremont is having the Lenin lighting to "Ring in the Holiday Season", I see that as "Ring in the Christmas Season".  (And what other season is rung in at this time of year?)

I have some difficulty with that combination since I know, as every educated person should, that Lenin does not go well with Christmas (or any other religious holiday).  In fact, after coming to power in the coup that overthrew the provisional government, Lenin banned all religious holidays.  And religious holidays stayed banned in the Soviet Union until 1992.

So I don't think lighting a statue of Lenin is the best way to celebrate Christmas (or any other religious holiday).  I was going to write a post needling our local papers for being unwilling to explain why some might object to this connection.  But it occurred to me that it would be even better to show them how they should cover both sides of this story.  It will be easy enough to get Fremont's side; I can just recycle what PI reporter Kery Murakami wrote in 2004, calling the same people and getting (most likely) the same quotes.

But covering the other side is a little harder, and that's where I would like your help.  I'd like to contact some of those Lenin and his successors persecuted, or scholars who know about that persecution.  I would like to contact members of the Russian Orthodox church, Cuban-American Catholics, Vietnamese-American Catholics, anyone, in short, who knows what it is like to try to "Ring in the Christmas Season" in a Communist country.  I have the feeling that not all of them see Lenin as an ideal Christmas ornament.  But I would like to talk to some of them to be sure.

If you, or someone you know, can help me cover the other side of this story, please email me directly: jimxc@jimxc.seanet.com.  And just like the reporters who get salaries for their work, I am willing to protect those who wish to be anonymous.

Finally, one curiosity: At their home page, the Fremont Chamber of Commerce wishes those who visit their site a "Merry Christmas".  I will not even try to explain that.

Posted by Jim Miller at December 12, 2006 08:12 PM | Email This
Comments
1. Happy Lenin lighting. Will the lights be red? I don't have a problem with lighting Lenin, my best guess is he is currently feeling a lot of heat. I don't have a problem with people celebrating the season however they want to. Merry Christmas to All.

Posted by: WVH on December 12, 2006 09:43 PM
2. You're kidding, right? Get a grip, get a life. People in Fremont call themselves the Center of the Universe. Enough said. Get on with your own holiday.

Posted by: westello on December 12, 2006 11:03 PM
3. What I wonder is, will the previous poster go down to Fremont and tell those people to "get a life"??

I didn't think so...

:~\

Posted by: BRC on December 13, 2006 05:11 AM
4. Lenin lighting? their right in America. my right also to dismiss kooks & nuts. freedom also means free to be a jackass. any of those 'lighters' live under other world regimes? probably not. who cares. like the naked parades in same neighborhood. clowns on a stage, nothing more.

Posted by: jimmie-howya-doin on December 13, 2006 05:19 AM
5. Good idea, Jim. Seems like most people posting here are saying "It's their right to be nuts" with the corresponding implication "so don't bother saying anything". But it's your right to "dialogue" (how's that for an ungrammatical liberal watchword?) with them. I hope you get a lot of responses of the kind you're looking for. Silence implies agreement, and nobody has a right to expect others to agree with them.

Posted by: sro on December 13, 2006 06:38 AM
6. I've been torn about Lenin since he was erected in Fremont. Part of me thinks it is a thumb in the eye of Russian Americans (I keep waiting to read that one of them has pulled the statue down ala Saddam). But another part likes to think that by erecting Lenin in the middle of capitalistic America (granted, Fremont is at the lunatic fringe, but capitalism is still practiced there), we are disgracing him, like putting him in stocks in the town square.

Maybe we should organize an egg throwing celebration.

Posted by: Organization Man on December 13, 2006 06:57 AM
7. Each time I walk by our old buddy Lenin, I chuckle, as to how well placed he is, in the Peoples Republic of Fremont.

Live and let live. It provides good entertainment for out of town friends, taking them to see him, and makes Lenin easier to see in the dark.

Peace out.

THE GEEZER

Posted by: The Geezer on December 13, 2006 08:46 AM
8. SRO:
"Silence implies agreement, and nobody has a right to expect others to agree with them."

Posted by sro at December 13, 2006 06:38 AM

What did you mean by the comment? I read a lot of the postings here and often don't reply. All my silence means is that I chose not to respond. As for the folks in Fremont, all I agree with is their right to have the kind of celebration of the season they choose to have.

Posted by: WVH on December 13, 2006 10:34 AM
9. I had no idea this was happening. It's bad enough they have a statue honoring a communist who persecuted people, but a lighting ceremony for it???? It's worse than I thought in Fremont.
The only way this isn't an outrage is if they put underwear on the statue's head during said ceremony.

Posted by: Michele on December 13, 2006 10:36 AM
10. #6 said erected... snicker snicker. :)

Posted by: El Diablo on December 13, 2006 12:52 PM
11. I imagine that the last thing Lenin would have wanted was to be decorated with Christmas lights, even if it was done in fun. There is certainly some justice here.

I think it's great that his statue adorns Fremont. Lenin always looked as if he was suffering from a monumental stomach-ache. A pleasant reminder for everyone of the ravages of communism.

Posted by: Bill Cruchon on December 13, 2006 02:42 PM
12. I've always dismissed the whole war on Christmas gig as right wing garbage, but given what I’ve seen from the right over the last couple of years I’ve decided that a war on Christmas is a great idea. Too bad no one is actually waging it.

Posted by: me on December 14, 2006 11:49 AM
13. I can guarantee a non-PC, authentic, MIND-BOGGLING Christmas experience: Go to see "It's A Wonderful Life: The Musical" at tne Northshore Performing Arts Center. Put on by the stellar Attic Theatre (go to theattictheatre.org for ticket information), this is top-shelf theater at a fraction of the cost. You can take the whole family for what one seat would cost downtown. If you want to be blown away by what Christmas is really all about, go see the magic that is this show! Even Lenin would need to bring his tissues!

Posted by: GetChristmasSpiritHere on December 14, 2006 03:37 PM
Post a comment
Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember info?