December 06, 2006
Clarence Page: "A Problem Bigger Than Busing"

Chicago Tribune editorial board member and columnist Clarence Page - an African-American - writes today about the Seattle schools student assignment "racial tiebreaker" now before the U.S. Supreme Court.

..the Louisville and Seattle public school racial-integration plans...offer troubling examples of the overreaching of "reverse discrimination" that affirmative action foes rail against...as Bill Cosby forcefully told civil rights leaders at the 50th anniversary of the Brown decision, what have we gained when the past half-century of desegregation has failed to close the academic achievement gap between blacks and Latinos on one side and whites and Asians on the other? Some of my fellow African-Americans were offended by Cosby's candor, but he spoke the truth. Close the grade and test-score gap and the affirmative action debate ends.

Unfortunately, we too often have seen school desegregation lead to further divisions in which black and Latino students are tracked into lower-performing classes and white and Asian students are tracked toward college. That problem is bigger than buses.

....we should be motivated to move to the next rational step for our liberation: the integration of low-income, low-achieving students into a higher-achieving future. It takes more than a bus to make that trip.

How? More uniform and rigorous curricula focused on core academic subjects; much stricter school discipline; no dilution of state graduation requirements; and an end to grade inflation and "social promotion." The impetus for all that in Seattle would be far greater with public charter schools, and greater still if vouchers for non-denominational private schools were added to the mix. But lacking both as we now do, the push for more consistent rigor and higher expectations in Seattle public schools must primarily come from the local black and Hispanic communities. A pre-condition is their eschewing "victim politics;" and the local media have a large role to play in this, as well.

Posted by Matt Rosenberg at December 06, 2006 10:17 AM | Email This
Comments
1. Sadly, academic achievement is not valued by all.

Posted by: Jack Burton on December 6, 2006 10:17 AM
2. More uniform and rigorous curricula focused on core academic subjects; much stricter school discipline; no dilution of state graduation requirements; and an end to grade inflation and "social promotion."

While those may help, the real key is parental involvement. See here for details:

http://andrews-dad.blogspot.com/2006/12/seattle-will-never-be-able-to-fix-its.html

Posted by: Steve on December 6, 2006 10:23 AM
3. More uniform and rigorous curricula focused on core academic subjects; much stricter school discipline; no dilution of state graduation requirements; and an end to grade inflation and "social promotion."

This may help at the fringe. What is really needed is more money.

/sarc

Posted by: Right said Fred on December 6, 2006 10:30 AM
4. 1. There should be one definition of basic education which is applicable to all schools.
2. Schools are like microclimates. A strong principal should be allowed to hire and fire all staff.
3. Schools should be given the flexibility to innovate to produce basic education in their population of students.
4. The current institutional structure will not allow #2 and #3 and power players who are beholden to the current stakeholders will advocate solutions like mayorial control, but will never look at whether the institutional structure needs to be changed. Expect more failure.

Posted by: WVH on December 6, 2006 10:52 AM
5. We will not have any real racial equality in the US until a generation or two after we stop having governmentally imposed inequality. We will not have equality of outcomes for an additiional generation or two after that.

Everyone has to each actually accept that the government is not going to step in and re-tilt things or put its thumb on the scale to anyone's benefit. Then everyone will have to knuckle down and do their own best (and stop holding each other down for "acting white" by trying to achieve). Then each group will see the same sort of progress over a few generations that other disfavored ethnic groups (e.g. Irish, Chinese) made in the past.

Posted by: krm on December 6, 2006 12:13 PM
6. Fred...actually, we don't need more money in education, we need to be more responsible where the money is spent because it certainly doesn't go the the classroom with the students.

Until the parents and students care about their education, no amount of money can change the situation.

Scrap Washington schools and start over, it's a pathetic and dysfunctional system.

Posted by: dl on December 6, 2006 03:27 PM
7. #1
Please allow me to take issue with educational achievement is not valued by all. We have all heard the phrase "that child must have been raised by wolves" and I don't mean the founders of Rome. I am not saying that people shouldn't be responsible for their actions, Dr. Bill Cosby is better at stating the issues. Many parents are ignorant, not stupid. They may not have the skills to navigate the bureaucracy and get a good education for their child. It is actually possible to get a good education in the Seattle schools, if one is politically savvy. Many parents are ignorant of the dangers that hip hop culture poses to their children. The children, without, positive role models are pretty much on their own. Unfortunately school is the refuge and resource for these kids. I have to chuckle that now Seattle University sponsors an etiquette dinner where kids whose parents haven't taught them the basics get to learn how to hold a fork and eat before going out into the world. Kids of all classes and hues attend. There is a lot more support than people realize. Even some of those kids one sees in hip hop garb are as Madonna says "striking a pose." They can be educated. The Weekly has a good article on the proposed Technology Academy at Rainier Beach.

Posted by: WVH on December 6, 2006 10:10 PM
Post a comment
Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember info?