October 31, 2006
Liberal Pundits and Leading Democarts Think You are Dumb...

...or racist. Take your pick.

The Seattle Times today ran E.J. Dionne's column, continuing the coverage of the RNC ad against Harold Ford that has had the chattering class in a tizy the last week. The Real Clear Politics blog has an excellent response from a Tennessee native to the charges that have been levied by liberals and sympathetic members of the national press corps:

We hicks in Tennessee see a man who has conducted most of his campaign from a church pew and, for some reason, had trouble explaining why he went to a Playboy party. Gosh darn, we have running water down here, and even flush toilets. Oh, but thanks for reminding me: I have to wash my sheets for the big Klan rally Saturday night. Who is indulging in stereotypes here? Who is obsessed with the notion of a black man and white woman getting together? None of the Tennessee hicks that I know, but apparently most of the enlightened members of the fourth estate in Washington and New York...

This gentlemen, in direct terms, has hit all the themes that first jumped out to many conservatives regarding this whole affair. Anyone who isn't going to vote for Harold Ford because he's African-American already made that decision a long time ago. The infatuation of assorted liberal pundits, Democrats, and interest groups with the racism charge only proves that they assume conservative leaning voters, especially in the South, are racist jerks. Republicans see a funny ad. Liberals assume Republicans are playing a race card, when there is none to play. The only bigots involved are the liberals who presume conservatives are racist.

Moreover, Ford is the one who first made this all an issue by shooting an ad in a church (which was abstractly pretty good by the way), but then couldn't clearly explain at first whether he was or was not at a Playboy party. I don't think lots of people care about the party in general, but it was his inconsistency that kept the issue alive. Accordingly, if that inconsistency is to be highlighted in an ad, what stereotype of an actress is supposed to be used to be the Playboy bunny other than a blond, white woman? Seriously, what other stereotype are people going to identify with? If anything Harold Ford should have been insulted that the actress isn't very attractive!

Conservatives do owe these outraged liberals some thanks though. The ongoing repetition of such charges, and liberal disdain over supposedly negative campaigning by Republicans (as opposed to the charming and sweet pro-Bush ads being run across the country by Democrats), only serves to remind Republicans of one of the things they hate the most: being told they're dumb, or worse, by people in the MSM.

Between E.J. Dionne and company, and John Kerry, the gift who keeps on giving, the Republican base has gotten quite an energy boost in the last week (for an excellent analysis of Kerry's stumble, read Jonah Goldberg's take at NRO's The Corner, as well as coverage of the gaffe's impact at the Real Clear Politics blog here and here). October surprise? It may already have been provided in unexpected terms.

Those interested in other recent coverage on the Harold Ford ad and related media follies see posts here, here, and here.

Posted by Eric Earling at October 31, 2006 01:36 PM | Email This
Comments
1. The funny part is that Kerry doesn't think he stumbled! He says he will apologize to no one.

Posted by: Right said Fred on October 31, 2006 01:42 PM
2. I'll vote for racist, but I could make an argument for dumb.

Posted by: RobK1967 on October 31, 2006 02:02 PM
3. You always "make an argument for dumb". Don't let us stop you now - you're on a roll...

Posted by: alphabet soup on October 31, 2006 02:32 PM
4. My dad was a very dark-skinned latin american, and my mom a very fair-skinned norwegian. Does that make them racist for getting married to each other? Does that make ME racist for being one of their offspring???

Posted by: Michele on October 31, 2006 02:54 PM
5. Why, Michele, that all depends on whether you intend to vote Democrat or Republican. If the former, congratulate yourself for celebrating your diversity. If the latter, you're nothing more than a proto-patriarchal salsa-soaked lutefisk.

Posted by: Rey Smith on October 31, 2006 02:59 PM
6. RobK, you vote for racists?

Posted by: RobK is a Knob, K? on October 31, 2006 03:43 PM
7. Ummmmmmmm salsa!

Posted by: alphabet soup on October 31, 2006 05:19 PM
8. No, so sorry coward, I do not vote for Republicans.

Posted by: RobK1967 on October 31, 2006 05:40 PM
9. Democrats love to prey on the ignorance and gullibility of the public. Why can't they not distort and tell the truth for a change ?
Why ? They know that a large majority of voters do not want income redistribution, more political correctness, higher taxes and generally less accountibility. So they have to package it up, exaggerate, spin and manufacture their campaign ads, which is nauseating and pi**es me off.

Republicans do it too, but to a lesser extent as I see it. The Republican agenda differs from the Democrat/Socialist agenda. It would be nice to see more conservative Democrats infiltrate into the leadership, but I won't hold my breath.

Posted by: KS on October 31, 2006 07:17 PM
10. As mediocre as Bush is in a number of areas, I am sure glad that John Kerry did not get elected President - oy vay !

Posted by: KS on October 31, 2006 07:20 PM
11. Robk #8: "No, so sorry coward, I do not vote for Republicans."

So, are you implying that Republicans are cowards by default, or just the individual who posted?

Posted by: YourLifeIsMyFault on October 31, 2006 07:22 PM
12. Rey: LOL!! Too funny! Very clever

Posted by: Michele on October 31, 2006 11:16 PM
13. #11, nope. That is not directed at all Repubs, heck there are even a few Republicans that I have voted for.

Posted by: RobK1967 on November 1, 2006 06:48 AM
14. It's true. I think Republicans are dumb, well mostly ignorant. I'm not joking, how can you ignore so much corruption and incompetance. Keep dreaming losers, America is tired of this neocon bullshit.

Posted by: Daniel J. on November 1, 2006 08:15 AM
15. Oh yeah, and for removing Habeas Corpus. I also think Republicans are traitors. Including the few Democrats who voted for it. Chew on that you filthy neocons. You're traitors to Democracy.

R.I.P

Constitution

Posted by: Daniel J. on November 1, 2006 08:23 AM
16. Exactly when did Habeas Corpus get removed? Why are Republican traitors? How about Ted Kennedy, is he a traitor too? I would suppose Baghdad Jim and Patty Murray are too then. Just want to make sure we know where you are coming from. Also, who are patriots in your view? Would people serving in our military be?

Posted by: Dengle on November 1, 2006 12:51 PM
Post a comment
Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember info?