It's no secret those of us at Sound Politics aren't exactly wildly impressed with the netroots (I've been directly critical here and here). Now, here's some great anecdotal evidence that supports one of the key critiques of the netroots movement: they're out of touch with much of America.
The local netroots enthusiasm for Darcy Burner is all over the liberal blogosphere. Recently, Lynn Allen, one of the main contributors to Evergreen Politics, recounted her experience doorbelling for Darcy. In the midst of her post, this line jumps out: "Most amazing to me, not a single person I talked with had heard of Darcy."
To be fair, I probably give more credit to Darcy's candidacy than some Sound Politics readers, but I still think much of the Democrats' enthusiasm in this race is misplaced (as one of my posts above expounds). The quote from Lynn Allen's experience certainly highlights the profound disconnect between the netroots and the voting public they actually need for their candidates to win general elections.
Posted by Eric Earling at August 05, 2006 11:21 AM | Email ThisAnd the rest of her little post is an apology in advance for losing the election.
Posted by: Cheryl on August 5, 2006 11:30 AMBut don't worry, it's just the lefty "nutroots." Reichert has it made. Just sit back and do nothing.
Posted by: ivan on August 5, 2006 11:51 AMIt's time to start asking these DarcyDoorbellers to prove they live in the 8th, are really rabid about darcy and not some talking point trolls.
Posted by: Cheryl on August 5, 2006 12:10 PMIf you're shocked at all by this, you don't know politics at all.
10% pay attention, and generally vote for the R or D dispite the news/issues.
And 90% wait for the TV to tell them what to do.
It's nothing new at all.
Posted by: Gerald on August 5, 2006 12:11 PMFirst, the story cited tells me: netrooters are being converted into precinct walkers.
Second, the volunteer's observation, "about half the folks definitely did not want Reichert re-elected." Certainly not conclusive, but an interesting anecdote that needs to be confirmed as valid or not.
SP needs to stop being dismissive, out of hand, of netrooters, if they are being converted into foot troops in the precincts. SP needs to ask, "Where are the R precinct troops?" "What are they learning from the voters?"
How many of the SP authors have hit the sidewalk and learned something valuable from your fellow voters, for your candidate?
The race will be won by those who show up in the precincts, not those who disparage each other online, sitting in front of their computers.
Posted by: NutsToU on August 5, 2006 12:21 PM***
tell us again... what's that record NetNuts is holding for getting candidate elected? 0/20?
Posted by: Cheryl on August 5, 2006 12:34 PMMy question though is, if SP posters are so hard on folks like Lynn who get excited about a somewhat unknown candidate, what are you doing yourself writing about topics that people don't typically get excited about?
I've always wondered why anyone who themselves write for a blog would deride the netroots, which on its own is a non-partisan distinction. A Republican, Democrat, Libertarian, etc.. could be a member of the netroots.
Posted by: Emmett O'Connell on August 5, 2006 12:34 PMSounds like they're using the King County voter registration roles.
Posted by: Darth Dogbert on August 5, 2006 12:39 PMThose of us that blog on sites such as this are here because we are more interested in politics than the average voter. We have not, however made it our lifes work like goldstein, huffington and the NetNuts have.
Posted by: Cheryl on August 5, 2006 12:40 PMI'l take it with a grain of salt. But I think it's worth noting that Darcy's real world name recognition is low. Which makes sense as this is her first appearance on the radar.
I still think that overall, Netroots enthusiasm is vastly amplified by a sympathetic and hopeful media. November will tell.
Posted by: Jeff B. on August 5, 2006 01:03 PMI would say the wider purprose, the reason why any of us, Democrat or Republican, discuss politics on the internet is to help develop a broader, more participatory, political discussion.
Posted by: Emmett O'Connell on August 5, 2006 02:11 PMIt is not unusual when walking a precinct to find voter registered at nonexistent addresses in King County
The people who had moved away were probably donors from a previous campaign of a Democrat candidate
Lynn Allen says "Even though no one had heard of Darcy, about half the folks definitely did not want Reichert re-elected."
Since they appear to be focusing on people who are mostly likely to vote Democrat, it is not unusual for half the folks to be anti Reichert
If all you do is read blogs and drink your party's Kool Aid, Lynn Allen and friends response is pretty typical
Posted by: Green Lake Mark on August 5, 2006 02:16 PMAmusing considering that Reichert is a moderate to liberal republican and really is not loved by strong conceravtes. But take my word for it, those strong conservatives that made up a good percentage of those that don�t like Reichert, will vote for him over a carpet bagging netroot.
1. I told them that I believe that Darcy is a "transformational" candidate, one of those people like Ned Lamont
If she is telling the majority of people this about Darcy Burner I think she may find it has the opposite effect seeing as most people that consider them selves moderates dont like what is happening to Joe Libberman out in Conn.
2. I've signed up to run for PCO in my own precinct in Seattle
why is it that everything I have heard about Burner is from people outside the district. Has she even done any rallies in her district or is she just concentrating all her efforts in Seattle?
Posted by: TrueSoldier on August 5, 2006 02:51 PMActually I canvassed for the Democratic Party before, and while we use the voter database we also keep other records. The point is to distinguish the R's from the D's so we know who to call on election day. Unfortunately, the lists don't stay accurate for long and when you think you have a D house, a lot of the time it's a R.
And actually the voter database is extremely inaccurate. The problem is people move without telling the state, and never re-register. So you knock on a door, ask for Jim, and hear "Ummm, no Jim lives here", so you look on the list again, "how about... Rhonda?".
I actually found the whole thing a complete waste of time, but whoever the big-shots are obviously think it helps.
Posted by: Gerald on August 5, 2006 04:48 PMMy guess though, which is just a guess, is that we didn't report it. Why would we want the opponents to have accurate data that we found out?
Yep. The whole system is a mess.
Posted by: Gerald on August 5, 2006 06:51 PMThe Republicrats and Demicans seem like one party at times on the national level, but are clearly different about other issues.
Things are different in the Socialist Republic of WA. You know and I know that the Democrats in this state are going to do everything humanly possible, whether its legal or not to retain power in November. Hopefully, enough people will awaken from their apathy to rise up and vote out these self-serving socialists that have a D beside their name and that goes especially for the incumbent judges in the WSSC and vote out Gregoire in '08.
Posted by: KS on August 5, 2006 09:31 PMCheryl, you blog? Blogging means writing your own posts on a blog. Commenting in comment threads is not blogging IMO. Let's get that distinction straight.
I agree with the rest of your statement however.
Posted by: Daniel K on August 6, 2006 12:26 AMIt's sad testimony to our times when folks are willing to be swayed by a single voice knocking on their door, or a television commercial. Sadly, most of the electorate votes with no more intelligence or reasoned choice than monkeys.
Posted by: Jeff B. on August 6, 2006 08:59 AMWho am I, well I am currently considering my options while sharing a loft with some buddies on Capital Hill and attending classes part time at Seattle Central Community College. No, I didn't know I was in Carnation, they just dropped me off and gave me this map to use to walk around and knock on doors. Actually no, I didn't know Seattle was that way and Yes I will make sure not to let the door hit me in the rear on the way out.
Posted by: Smokie on August 6, 2006 10:30 AMhome free
Posted by: righton on August 6, 2006 06:12 PM