July 06, 2006
Seattle Sub-Bourgeoisie Angst & The Revolutionary Dialectic

Seattle Weekly's George Howland does the whole soup-to-nuts rundown on the commited anarchists residing at the Emma Goldman Finishing School collective in Seattle's Beacon Hill neighborhood. I'm glad to hear their vegan-only food supply is only partially harvested from dumpsters. But when it comes to having children and a place to call one's own, well, it seems the rhetoric meets the road.

If you live at Emma's...you cannot own a car, but for four hours of labor a week, you can join Emma's car co-op with three vehicles, all equally decrepit....Even after 10 years and countless hours of labor, Emma's house looks like a dump. Three of the sides are covered with a hideous green asbestos siding that needs a paint job (one member reportedly moved out when the group refused to paint the house). The back of the house has prettier wood siding, but it's painted different colors as if someone had started a paint job but never bothered to finish it. The most prominent feature of the front yard is a Plexiglas cover for a pickup truck that lays molding next to the stairs. The stairs themselves are rotten enough that their replacement seems like a safety concern....there currently are no children in the house....Kristen Walsh...was a member for three years (but she) and her husband, Brandon Faloona...moved out before the birth of their son, Azure. They now own their own home.....Says Walsh, "Ultimately, I do believe property is theft, yet I want some security for myself and my child."

Original member ("housing activist" Bob) Kubiniec, who left five years ago after five years of residence, now has three children and a stepdaughter. "You want to be generous with your kids. That austere an arrangement would interfere with that. I'm not comfortable making my children suffer for my deviant political beliefs," says Kubiniec.

Gee. That last punchy phrase might also be an apt description, sadly, of sending your children to Seattle public schools these days. Myself, I'm a stubborn city-dwelling coot; my wife, too. Even with the added and difficult expense of private schools, like that guy with the black eye in the old Tareyton cigarette commercial on TV and in print, we'd "rather fight than switch." The more people who live here that are even remotely like those profiled by Howland in The Weekly, the greater the need for a middle-class cultural revolution in The Great Emerald City. These hairy-minded folk - who think meat is murder, Bush is the anti-Christ, and property is "theft" - are just plain scary. Not because their views are outright anywhere near the majority, or because most Seattle-ites live in places like the Emma Goldman Finishing School (they don't, of course). But because the underpinning socialist gospels of managed outcomes, moral relativism, "critical theory" and deconstructionism are never far from the surface of the city's political consciousness, Seattle's costly governance, our exceedingly lame and PC MSM "straight news" reportage, our increasingly far-fetched K-20 public classroom curricula, and our polarizing "progressive" activism. The Good News: we DON'T have to take it anymore.

Posted by Matt Rosenberg at July 06, 2006 09:41 PM | Email This
Comments
1. Damn right we don't have to take it anymore! I moved in to the Capitol Hill neighborhood last December because I thought living on Republican Street would be cool (actually I found a great apartment, but the street name doesn't hurt). My neighbors didn't like my Mike McGavick sign or American flag dwelling in the window. Leftists in my neighborhood think they can get away with the crazed rhetoric and moonbat activism -- well I'm here to help put an end to that.

My new project is called Radical Seattle -- and I welcome any SP readers help in documenting and standing up to the sheer insanity of the nutty liberals running our local government!

Posted by: Patrick on July 6, 2006 11:02 PM
2. Those two quotes are just hilarious.
Really--eating regularly out of a dumpster when it's not really necessary?? (I know some people do it for recreation, but this seems to be a requirement). This is the face of the democrat party. Why? Too many on the KC council and the KC executive also seem to believe that owning property is theft (if you live in east King County, that is). But they don't seem to believe that stealing it from me is theft.

Posted by: Misty on July 6, 2006 11:19 PM
3. Actually you DO have to take it. Lib's are a sizable majority in Seattle. :)

By the way I could paint you a picture of some militia compounds or religious monostaries that sound almost excatly the same as theis co-op. We all have our oddballs. The beauty of a free country is that, with in some bounds, we are all free to live as we want. Nothing is more classically conservative then not wanting the government to tell you how to live.

Posted by: Giffy on July 7, 2006 03:21 AM
4. Kristen Walsh still thinks property is theft, but she bought (stole?)some property because she wants some security for herself and her child.

So what's good and secure for her and her child is morally wrong?

It appears that she has no moral committment to the principle, "Thou shalt not steal."

If she is willing to commit theft because she wants security for her and her child, I wonder what she would do if she wanted your bicycle for her and her child.

Posted by: ken on July 7, 2006 08:37 AM
5. What a great article. I knew people like these 35 years ago. The anti-capitalist rhetoric is virtually identical.

Look at the photos of these people. The women in particular already have faces that seem to be frozen in pinch-faced anger. And they're only in their 20's and 30's. The nutty left is defined by their anger which is why studies show that righties are generally happier than lefties. I'm sure one of their decrepit vehicles sports their favorite bumper sticker, "if you're not outraged, you're not paying attention".

As always these kooks manage to take advantage of capitalism, (they seem to have computers, internet access, and get their dumpster meals from the fruits of capitalists) while decrying its evils. Not surprising is the high turnover rate. If you have half a brain it doesn't take long to get sick of this crap.

The real test of their convictions would be to homestead in the wilderness where it wouldn't be so convenient to sponge off of people who actually do things. At least that would get them out of Seattle...for a while.

Posted by: Bill Cruchon on July 7, 2006 09:29 AM
6. I'm sure they all have bicycles. Why else all the bicyle paths talking up road space? I often think of these 20 somethings on bicycles growing up (!) and having children to raise. Now we hear they(shock) buy houses... could it be that they also at some dim time in the future... go grocery shopping with multiple children, in a CAR?

Posted by: ljm on July 7, 2006 10:55 AM
7. Ummm, doesn't something have to be property before it can be stolen? Otherwise, who is the theif taking it from?

Posted by: cp on July 7, 2006 11:26 AM
8. After reading the entire article (I was fascinated by it), I was actually enouraged. It sounds to me like most of the people who have participated in this commune have learned that their philosophies may be great in theory, but when put into practice, don't really work out as well as expected. Hopefully, they leave with a new understanding of why the world works the way it does (i.e. capitalism).
What they are basically practicing here is communism, and it appears that many of the members are discovering, through the actual practice of communism, that there are problems with it, even when implemented at such a small scale as this. It's a great teacher and the more "communism-minded" people that learn this lesson through actually getting a chance to put their theories to test, the more likely they will abandon these ideals and realize that good 'ole American capitalism and democracy aren't such a bad thing.

Posted by: lmk on July 7, 2006 12:04 PM
9. Kristen Walsh...was a member for three years (but she) and her husband, Brandon Faloona...moved out before the birth of their son, Azure. They now own their own home.....Says Walsh, "Ultimately, I do believe property is theft, yet I want some security for myself and my child."

Hmmm...a philosophy that says that you can either live, or be moral...is doomed to failure, and pure evil.

Some posters have pointed out the contradiction...we on the right do not depend upon that which we consider to be immoral. We do not require bums to provide for our families, we do not depend upon dumpster divers for groceries...we do not rely upon criminals to make our families safe. Yet these...things...exist only upon the generosity and morality of those they despise. Ayn Rand was right.

Posted by: South County on July 7, 2006 08:09 PM
Post a comment
Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember info?