June 19, 2006
Wanna Buy A Newspaper?

The King County Journal is up for sale. Current ownership says it can't afford to bring the publication and other smaller papers it owns to their full potential. More from the Seattle Times and the the Seattle Post-Intelligencer, the latter of which will likely be dead and buried soon, as legal proceedings unfold around the Joint Operating Agreement still keeping the financially untenable fishwrap alive. The P-I's death won't be mourned by any truly sentient being, but the KCJ's impending sale by Horvitz Newspapers Inc. of Kent is sad at first. The KCJ offered a sane editorial voice that often stands in contrast to the entrenched liberal sympathies of editorialists at Seattle's two dailies. But ultimately, it's a smart business move and could offer some hope to readers and an important corner of The Republic, if a well-heeled buyer or purchase consortium materializes. Because despite the occasional story that bested competition from Seattle's dailies, the KCJ was nowhere near its potential. This has been especially evident in poor staffing, too much filler, its failure to do high-impact investigatory reporting and more sophisticated local news coverage, and an inability or unwillingness to embrace the online realm.

Yes, they had a Web site, but until recently it totally stank, and now there's a bit more news but still no real interactivity, especially with respect to the blogosphere. Newspapers need to be allying with blogs and blog readers, because readers increasingly "unbundle" the news from any one purveyor, choosing only the stuff that matters, and then using tools such as Google News and the filtering of bloggers they like to tap other sources. Good "unbundled" stuff from Seattle's dailies sometimes (but not often enough) includes the local news; plus occasionally sane op-eds; and material from Western WA's only newspaper poli-blogger who actually gets it.

McClatchy Chairman and CEO Gary Pruitt tells American Journalism Review that newspapers must leverage off their local print publications a whole range of other assets, "including, most importantly, the leading local Internet site." That involves not only strong usability features, but an avoidance of "Chinese Menu" cross-demographic pandering in favor of news, analysis and opinion content drawn from the regional blogosphere.

In my wildest dreams there are some Net-savvy, blogsmart Eastsiders right now ruminating about buying The King County Journal and the sister publications also up for sale. Already facing pressures in the online era, dailies in Puget Sound and around the U.S. have sometimes helped hasten their own demise with inexcusable errors of omission and bias. True, newspapers do things that most often, blogs cannot. But if the market is not there for an unrealized suburban daily on the Eastside, the challenge then just falls more heavily on some percentage of bloggers within that catchment area to learn how to practice citizen journalism. That's something increasingly part of the mix nationwide, no matter what. It will be especially interesting to see funding strategies evolve in this area over the coming five to ten years. Especially around Seattle, where the circulation of dailies continues to decline.

Posted by Matt Rosenberg at June 19, 2006 04:56 PM | Email This
Comments
1. I really don't think I should be the first one to comment for the very obvious reasons. But that's never stopped me:-)
The Mercer Island Reporter and the bi-monthly Reporter Newspaper publications (Bellevue, Redmond, Bothell/Kenmore, Renton, Kent, Auburn and Covington) are making money which proves the thesis I've frequently expressed here that community news is the future for the industry.

Posted by: Reporterward on June 19, 2006 05:38 PM
2. Matt,

I have to disagree with you on your assertation that having a good website is necessary for a successful newspaper. That just does not pass muster and, in practice, quite the opposite is the case.
Locally, the Seattle Post-Intelligencer has the best web publication in the area in terms of getting material out to the public (we're not talking content mind you). As we all know, the PI is floundering financial due to poor circulation numbers.
The Tacoma News Tribune, on the other, embargoes all of its news for up to a day on their website. As a consequence, their circulation figures are up. The TNT also makes a pretense of covering local news in the South Puget Soung region.

Posted by: Reporterward on June 19, 2006 05:47 PM
3. I don't mind the concept of using bloggers as a resource. In fact I've been doing a crash course in that hanging out with y'all.
I have yet (and I've been racking my brain over this) to figure out how to make money off of blogs. And in this business that means advertising dollars.

Posted by: Reporterward on June 19, 2006 05:50 PM
4. I've been subscribing to the local Enumclaw paper for over 5 years now. I get local news with a definite right lean; news about new local businesses, city business, local sports and varying supplements for the different seasons regarding what's happening in the area.

I haven't thought twice about going back to the mainstream rags.

Oh! it's only $40 for two full years home delivery, (Ok, I have to travel a mile to pick it up from the box)

Posted by: MSRedneck on June 19, 2006 06:05 PM
5. I cancelled the Seattle Times about 10 years ago... the homosexual agenda was heating up and the Times pushed me over the brink when they had articles like 'high-schoolers going steady' which had to highlight a lesbian couple and 'women in traditionally male jobs' and had to highlight a lesbian plumber. It was the plumber that pushed me over the edge. It was just so unnecessary to bring up this clearly capable womans sexual preference.

Quite frankly, I don't care, nor can control, what homosexuals do, but I most certain do care about being slapped in the face with it at my own kitchen table by I paper I pay for and I can control it by cancelling that offending paper.

They kept calling for years trying to get me to re-subscibe. Instead, they got an earful.

Posted by: Cheryl on June 19, 2006 08:00 PM
6. The best newspaper in my area still tells the readers who had lunch with who and how they are related. People want gossip and opinions that agree with their own. That is all it takes to be a successful newspaper.

Posted by: Elaine on June 19, 2006 09:39 PM
7. It's about time that poor shuffling zombie, the Seattle P-I, went to the Great Printing Press in the Sky. I blame the Seattle Times for foisting this putrid corpse on the public so it could maintain it's intellectual and financial hegemony in the Seattle market.

Of course the Times will start running those self-serving ads about how the po' little ole Seattle Times is about to gobbled up or run out of business by some big media giant and it would sure be nice if some laws were passed to prevent it.

Well boo frigging hoo. The sooner the Times joins it's soul sister the better.

Posted by: Bill K. on June 19, 2006 11:20 PM
8. i prefer local papers, but found many here on the North End too liberal-leaning and light; no surprise; at least they are not packed full with too much diversity and victim agenda items on every other page; the larger papers haven't truly done any good BALANCED investigative, interesting journalism for many years--gone are the days of the non-p.c. tough journalist; now, it's all a victim game recital of excuses and kid glove interviews; no one interviewed is held to the fire like days past; inaccuracies are brushed over & fact corrections buried;

Posted by: Jimmie-howya-doin on June 20, 2006 03:47 AM
9. The KCJ offered a sane editorial voice that often stands in contrast to the entrenched liberal sympathies of editorialists at Seattle's two dailies.

I wondered about the wisdom of using the NY Times as their primary commentary and news source. I wouldn't subscribe to the NY Times for a minute; offering Mo and Tom and Krugman didn't make the paper any more attractive to me.

That said, their editorial page was at least more sane than the alternatives.

Posted by: South County on June 20, 2006 07:27 AM
10. We long ago quit reading the Seattle rags & quit the KCJ when it stopped some of its conservative columnists a few years ago. It just wasn't printing any news or information that interested us. We occasionally buy the Sunday edition of the KCJ just to get the TV guide, which is tons better than the one in the Seattle papers.

We won't be missing the demise of any of them.

Posted by: Clean House on June 20, 2006 10:32 AM
11. I've enjoyed the KCJ for years, and would hope that any buyers would keep the localness to the region. For anyone interested in High School or college sports, nothing beats the KCJ. I agree that sometimes they do run to many AP filler stories, but other times a full page spread on all the camps in the area is helpful when making that decision. Its a piece that the times or PI wouldn't have the room to print. Things go on out here in Issaquah, Renton, Bellvue, and Kent that just doesn't get covered in the larger papers.

Posted by: Jason on June 20, 2006 11:21 AM
Post a comment
Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember info?