April 17, 2006
Tax Day Open Comments

Take a break from filing your federal tax return or extension and share your feelings about high taxes and bloated wasteful government, or something.

Posted by Stefan Sharkansky at April 17, 2006 01:08 PM | Email This
Comments
1. OK, I'll vent: My family (and many others) are paying waaay more than our "fair share" of income taxes and I'm thankful that at least president Bush recognizes that and tried to do something about it with the tax cuts. They should be made permanent. In fact, they should be a flat 10% for everyone. Period.

Posted by: Misty on April 17, 2006 01:15 PM
2. I pay

36% Federal Income Tax

12.4% Self Employment Tax

2.9% Medicare Tax

8.9% Sales Tax

Outrageous property tax, liquor tax, phone tax, etc, etc, etc.

Posted by: swassociates on April 17, 2006 01:16 PM
3. 1 Just completed the 1st pass to put the return on extension and determine how much I can deduct for retirement
2 I don't mind paying taxes, but get excited when elected officials decide they know better than you and waste money on baseball and football stadiums and other Greater Seattle area foolishness
3 We need to pay for the schools and public libraries, but unfortuneately the officials waste a lot of money on nonvalue added services and cry baby millionare team owners
4 Gotta go to the post office

Posted by: Green Lake Mark on April 17, 2006 01:17 PM
4. I used to be a logger. I'd cut down a tree and make a profit of $20. What are my taxes?
No wait...If I take a tree to the top of the Federal Building and throw it off, how much will my taxes go up by the time it hits the ground?
No...dang it, that isn't right either.
Ok, how much did the per capita tax rate in King County change with each discovery of new ballots?
Extra credit, how many miles of new Vidaduct will that build?
Oh to hell with it. File the extension and go to Hooters for lunch where figures make sense!

Posted by: Diogenes on April 17, 2006 01:20 PM
5. Reasons a flat or consumption tax will never happen:

1. No tax code for politicians and special interests to tinker with

2. No more social engineering through the tax code

3. Eliminates an entire multi billion dollar industry dedicated to tax preparation

Feel free to add your own...

Posted by: Palouse on April 17, 2006 01:21 PM
6. All I have to say is that we need a true fair tax. I never thought about this till recently but the IRS is designed to collect all federal tax money, but then uses that money to make sure it is getting as much of that money as possible and everything else they can not get, they use more tax money to prosecute. So they spend federal tax money to collect federal tax money...logical? Not in my book. We need a constitutional amendment that will solve all this. FAIR TAXES FOR ALL!!!

Posted by: tax hater on April 17, 2006 01:31 PM
7. Elections should always be held the first Tuesday after the April 15 tax deadline.

Posted by: Huey on April 17, 2006 01:32 PM
8. Single people who don't own homes totally get screwed! At least, I thought, I'll be able to deduct the sales tax this year, but no..that only works if you can itemize...I can't do that because I can't afford to own my own home in Seattle (living in the ghetto isn't an option for a single female). With real estate skyrocketing way it is, my wages will never catch up, I'll have to move out of King County to buy. They need to fix the tax code so young, single people who actually have professional jobs and contribute to society don't get screwed!

Posted by: SweetNSassy on April 17, 2006 01:44 PM
9. Long live the Bush Tax Cuts!!

I just made a check out for $16k to make up for my dismal estimated tax for last year. The year before I binged on equipment for my office and a new business and was able to deduct the whole package. So, I just got done with a year of estimated taxes at 3k total. That extra 16k was collecting more interest if it wasn't also getting 7% interest on a loan or as an investment into future earnings.

I also had to pay income on the return on my investment. But, it was all deferred.

Without the Bush tax cuts, I wouldn't have been a player, even at the meager levels I am on.

Long live the Bush Tax Cuts!!!

Posted by: swatter on April 17, 2006 01:44 PM
10. Sassy, I know many people who started out buying a condo in Seattle that was pretty affordable and they were able to itemize. Then they were able to sell it and buy a place outside the city that was affordable. We live out in unincorporated KC and there are houses that are still affordable, if you don't mind doing a little commuting.

Posted by: Palouse on April 17, 2006 01:53 PM
11. I wish that sales tax deduction would get renewed. If moc's from our state want something to do, take care of that.

Posted by: Palouse on April 17, 2006 01:55 PM
12. I'll join in.

I'd like somebody to explain to me when the educational industrial complex will finally find sufficient - or as they say, ample - funding?

BTW, ample means "Fully sufficient to meet a need or purpose" in this discussion.

Posted by: A Watchdog on April 17, 2006 01:59 PM
13. This year's federal budget is around $2.7 trillion. In 2015, with every penny of the Social Security surpluses trust fund spent to reduce deficits, the government will have an immediate shortfall in revenues for Social Security and Medicare and these programs will each need an immediate influx of new revenue to make their payments to beneficiaries.

The Concord Coalition estimates that between 2015 and 2080, there will be a $67 trillion dollar shortfall of revenues to satisfy the promises made by our government to the elderly, based on current taxation and benefit schemes. By 2035, Medicare's deficits will equal Social Security deficits and be on a pace to double SSI deficits by 2080.

If you think your federal taxes are too high today, you ain't seen nothing yet! The Democrats have made reforming these programs impossible, and the medias' collusion in this scandal is sickening.

Posted by: MJC on April 17, 2006 02:00 PM
14. Palouse - wait another 5 or so years, you will be able to pick up property really cheap, if you have cash. With 1/3 of the US population being baby-boomers our economy is going to hit the skids! Mansions for back taxes...

Posted by: Fred on April 17, 2006 02:12 PM
15. I wish - well, one can dream... - that the practice of witholding from paycheck is abolished. Then, everyone will feel the same way as small business owners who have to grudgingly write a check each quater or however frequent the collection day comes.

Without the practice, I am willing to bet my farm that there'd be far fewer taxes with far smaller rates.

Anyone (in government, that is) want to take on my bet?

Posted by: C. Oh on April 17, 2006 02:15 PM
16. Not only should we have tax day just before elections day, we should also get rid of all withholding throughout the year, and all taxes other than income taxes. This way we could see exactly how much we spend in taxes total just before an election.
(obviously this will never happen, but I can dream)

Posted by: Jason Woodruff on April 17, 2006 02:39 PM
17. Speaking of the education industry, somehow this Sedro-Woolley School District nursery at State Street High has to close that was underadvertised. Which means more kids at the teat of welfare, unable to get an education to support their kids. Stupid policy and lackluster leadership I daresay. I also daresay that's not in short supply in Sedro-Woolley.

When I did the yearbook in my senior year long, long ago this (now-24 yr. old and still a) virgin got sent over... there. I volunteered for the tough assignment. That's my nature.

That said, State Street High School is your typical dumping ground alternative high school, full of kids who simply need a kick in the hind quarter. And for-the-record Michelle Turek is one of the good guys.

Posted by: A Watchdog on April 17, 2006 02:56 PM
18. I don't mind paying taxes for essential services such as fire, roads, education, etc. I don't like paying taxes for union leadership in the WEA, Sound Transit and other mindlessly lossy transit failures, ridiculous art and welfare projects, stadium renovation, envionmental studies, etc. And I'm especially upset when pork earmarks in the US budget go to pet projects in the districts of politicians such as the Bridge to Nowhere in Alaska.

We'll just keep taxing ourselves until it looks like Sweden here if we are not careful. And it's bad on both sides, but worse on the Democrat side.

I suggest all put on Robert Cray's "1040 Blues" and crank it. I'm going to press play right after I post this comment.

Posted by: Jeff B. on April 17, 2006 02:59 PM
19. I added up my federal taxes, property taxes, gas taxes, utility taxes and sales taxes to find that over 40% of my household income this year went to federal, local and the state. this amounted to approximately $35k.

Not much incentive to work hard and try to make something more of yourself.

Posted by: Ken on April 17, 2006 03:52 PM
20. I'll bite.

Most significantly: What can be done so that people get the relative difference between the scale of the federal government versus state government?

If folks realized how much they are shipping off to DC, and took a moment to contemplate what they are getting for it . . .

Just thumbnail estimates:
The feds spend roughly $7,500 each year for every man, woman and child in the country.

The state is spending roughly $4,700 per person.

States cannot spend into debt or steal from other states. States have line item vetoes and a part time legislature.

10th Amendment anyone?

Posted by: GentleRant on April 17, 2006 04:21 PM
21. Local, state and federal taxation now soaks up between 35 and 40% of gross domestic product.
So we are now almost 2/5 of the way to pure communistic socialism. You work Monday and Tuesday of each five-day week as a slave to the government.

In the last six years, non-defense domestic spending has grown at an average rate of 8% per year under a Republican contolled Senate, House and white house.

Power corrupts. We need true fiscal conservatives in government.

When the government takes this much more than is necessary to preserve our equal, individual rights to life, liberty and property, it is reduced to nothing more than a pack of thieves. The gang and the government are now no different.

If you are not outraged, you are not paying attention.

I don't have the guts, but I admit that anyone who uses non-violent civil disobedience against the IRS by not paying their taxes is a hero to me.

I see it as my moral duty to earn less money so that the government theives get less, and thus have less power over peaceful people.

This confiscatory taxation winds up hurting the poor through reduced job growth, even though the do-gooders in government try to justify their theft by saying they are helping the poor.

I say rubbish.

Posted by: Alexis de Toqueville on April 17, 2006 04:54 PM
22. see the most recent issue of the economist magazine for a discussion on the merits of the bush tax cut. popular wisdom may give way to facts on the beneficial effects to the country.

as for me, well i would expect a better return for the amount we pay in taxes. i feel like we have 3rd rate politicians squandering hard-earned dollars. politicians (regardless of party affiliation) have proven themselves incapable of managing other people's money. if the federal govt were a publicly traded corporation, i don't believe they could pass a GAAP audit. it's borderline criminal.

Posted by: dinesh on April 17, 2006 04:55 PM
23. One of the first things voters need to do is quit believing all the doom & gloom from the special interests and education. The voters should never vote to increase their own taxes for anything. They should make the legislature do it & make them accountable. If its not good enough for the legislature to support, then it should be voted down. If that happened often enough, the special interests and other would finally give up. But they know that parents and grandparents are suckers for the "do it for the children" lobby, so all the special levies are passed and then people wonder why their property taxes are so high.

Posted by: Clean House on April 17, 2006 05:56 PM
24. End withholding. Everyone writes a check once a year to IRS, FICA, SS, the state.

Tax day is the day before election day.

Consumption tax.

Flat rate tax.

Feds following the 10th amendment.

Finding a few fiscal conservative for the Republican party.

Anybody really serious about tax reform?

No!

To much power, too much money for reelection in the current system.

Posted by: JCM on April 17, 2006 06:07 PM
25. Thank God (and the Republicans)for tax credits!!

For 3 years straight I've enjoyed some wonderful refunds. I especially enjoy the "state" tax credit we can now claim! It gives me joy to get something back from this awful liberal tax-thieving state!

It's also wonderful to receive credits for young children! I'm sure that angers the child-less,gay,pro-abortion liberals here in Washington state!

Posted by: Deborah on April 17, 2006 07:14 PM
26. In 2004, only 44% of Tacoma residents paid any Federal Tax!!!

In 2004 in Pacific Grove Ca. 92% of the residents paid Federal Tax!!!

I wonder why the Homeless and Crime Rate in Pacific Grove is LOWER???

Posted by: Pacific Grove Phlash on April 17, 2006 08:01 PM
27. Re Deborah. Uhhhh Child tax credits are usually democratic proposals. R's tend to not like tax credits.

I for one am happy to pay my share. I enjoy the roads I drive on, the military to protect me, the social services to help those in need, and the research that keeps me healthy and living well. Taxes are a patriotic duty.

Posted by: Giffy on April 17, 2006 09:02 PM
28. Liar....

Posted by: alphabet soup on April 17, 2006 09:13 PM
29. Stay with me on this. The government needs to give back the taxes they collected when folks converted their Traditional IRAs to Roth IRAs while they unknowingly held stocks of corporations that cooked books. Said companies were later caught and stock prices plummeted. Investors were paying the government taxes for up to four years, spread out, on stocks that fetch a fraction today. No one in Congress talks about this. In a way, the Government is an accomplice to the crime, as they raked in the temporary capital gain.

Posted by: Uncle Sweets on April 17, 2006 10:12 PM
30. Neal Boortz, co-author of The Fair Tax Book, said that the tax return for GM will be over 50 fet high.

There are estimates that compliance with the tax code will cost businesses and the public $300-500 billion. That's money that isnt being used to expand businesses, create jobs or new technologies. Neal Boortz has a lot to say about taxes today at his site: boortz.com

Posted by: wanting reform on April 17, 2006 10:43 PM
31. "Re Deborah. Uhhhh Child tax credits are usually democratic proposals. R's tend to not like tax credits."

Well THAT'S crap.
As a homeowner and a parent who's paid taxes for many years....looking for every deduction and credit, from administration to administration - I can tell you that the Democrats are NOT tax credit friendly! It wasn't until Bush and a Republican congress passed the child tax credit! They are also the ones who sent refund checks out to families after 9/11 in the average amount of 300.00. They have also increased the child tax credit annually since their creation of that credit. They have also added states with no state income tax to the state sales tax refund's on the federal returns. Cantwell tried to take credit for that but it was already in discussion when she voted for it...

Now...about the road maintenance paid for with my tax dollars? You're joking - right? Not only does this state tax my tax dollars for non-existent road repair - but they now tax my gasoline purchases through the roof for the very same thing! And yet - the roads still suck! In fact - the Democrats are famous for that sucking sound coming from my pocketbook....

Open your eyes! Quit being the fool.


Posted by: Deborah on April 17, 2006 11:27 PM
32. Folks, as far as fair taxes, there is only one: A per-capita tax assessed to the states. States that don't perform economically will not be able to shoulder their tax as easily as states that do. It is a powerful incentive to allow businesses to grow /faster/ than other states.

The income tax is not a tax on the rich: It is a tax on people who are creating wealth in this country. It is amazing that despite the income tax, America is as productive as it is.

A flat tax is still a tax on wealth generation, and would still serve the purposes of harming our economy and economic liberty. Ask yourself: If you raised the tax rates high enough, what would be the effect? Everyone but the rich must generate income, and to do so, they would have to produce vast amounts of wealth. High taxes still get collected, because people still need to eat.

A sales tax too is oppressive. The federal government should have no right to intrude on a business and demand to see its sales receipts, nor to intrude on individuals and demand to see its purchase receipts (5th amendment and all). Although the safety valve is built in (high taxes = no (legal) commerce = no money for the government), it is still intrusive.

Let the states determine the most efficient way to raise money, and let the states shoulder the burden of collecting it. I would much rather live in a country where I could flee oppressive and intrusive taxes than one where there is no escape!

And one more thing, if you want reduced spending, stop accepting money from the federal government. All those highways they build--turn down the money. All those programs they support? Stop participating in them. Yes, there is a bit of "I want my piece of the pie back", but it all ends up in pigs feeding at the trough. Make a decision to stop being a pig and stop feeding at the trough, and demand that others do the same. As long as we demand money for this and that, we will always have congress extorting the money from the people.

Posted by: Jonathan Gardner on April 17, 2006 11:56 PM
33. Re Deborah
It was CLINTON who passed the first child tax credit. In 1995 I believe though it may have been 1998. He proposed it to congress who then passed it. In the latest tax cuts it was democrats who insisted that a child tax credit be part of the bill.

Generally Rupublicans usually favor simply cutting the rates (i.e. income, capital gains, sales) wereas Democrats favor target tax relief usually focusing on low and middle income earners. (i.e. Health care credits, education credits, child credits etc)

Posted by: Giffy on April 18, 2006 06:55 AM
34. "Republicans believe every day is the Fourth of July, but the democrats believe every day is April 15." - Ronald Reagan

"Government's view of the economy could be summed up in a few short phrases: If it moves, tax it. If it keeps moving, regulate it. And if it stops moving, subsidize it." - Ronald Reagan

Posted by: SouthernRoots on April 18, 2006 10:14 AM
35. "A democracy cannot exist as a permanent form of government. It can exist only until the voters discover they can vote themselves largesse (defined as a liberal gift) out of the public treasury. From that moment on, the majority always votes for the candidate promising the most benefits from the public treasury, with the result that democracy always collapses over a loose fiscal policy, always to be followed by a dictatorship."

- - Alexander Fraser Tytler (1748-1813)

Posted by: RBW on April 18, 2006 11:26 AM
36. Finally, some REASON on this board!

2 I don't mind paying taxes, but get excited when elected officials decide they know better than you and waste money on baseball and football stadiums and other Greater Seattle area foolishness

You don't understand, my good man, it's good for the economy! Those stadiums produce a few dozen badly needed part-time, living (read: minimum) wage jobs. But how dare you criticize the benevolent rich people who have inherited, erm, stolen, erm, earned the money and who pay their 3% fair share of taxes. What are you, some kind of "tur-ist"?

4 Gotta go to the post office

Hope ya got there before midnight.

Posted by: Critical THINKER on April 20, 2006 08:23 PM
37. OK, I'll vent: My family (and many others) are paying waaay more than our "fair share" of income taxes and I'm thankful that at least president Bush recognizes that and tried to do something about it with the tax cuts. They should be made permanent.

Oh? What have Bush's tax cuts done besides (1) throw us into a deficit (from a surplus) and (2) made the top 0.5% income households even richer?

In fact, they should be a flat 10% for everyone. Period.

Agreed, and I would apply it across the board, including to corporations like Ingersoll-Rand and Accenture. You know, the ones who locate their offices in tax havens like Bermuda to avoid paying income tax? Fact is, many large, very profitable corporations pay no income tax whatsoever. So, when you write out that check, what you're really doing is writing a check to some corporate fatcat.

Food for thought.

Posted by: Critical THINKER on April 20, 2006 08:28 PM
38. I pay

Not enough, I'll bet.

36% Federal Income Tax

That's cause you're a winner of life's lottery. And it's only 36% of the upper part of your earnings. Quit being so damn greedy.

12.4% Self Employment Tax

Being self-employed is a choice. Don't want to pay the tax? I hear Wal-Mart is hiring. Go work there, that's where the rest of us will be working in a few years. Or McDonald's.

2.9% Medicare Tax

Chump change.

8.9% Sales Tax

Wouldn't a state income tax be more fair?

Outrageous property tax,

On outrageously valuable property, thanks to the real estate bubble.

liquor tax,

Don't drink. It's bad for you.

phone tax, etc, etc, etc.

Want roads to drive your Hummer/RX500/Escalade on? Want the cops to show up when it gets a 1/8" dent in it? I thought so. Then shut the hell up and write the damn check.

Posted by: Critical THINKER on April 20, 2006 08:34 PM
39. I used to be a logger. I'd cut down a tree and make a profit of $20. What are my taxes?

I pity you. The same way I would have pitied a buggywhip maker when cars were invented. I'm oh-so-sorry that you can't make your living by raping the planet and mowing down the remaining 3% of old-growth forest that remains. Question: If the "managed forests" are working so well, why do the bastards at Weyerhaeuser, et al, want to log more old-growth?

Posted by: Critical THINKER on April 20, 2006 08:38 PM
40. Reasons a flat or consumption tax will never happen:

1. No tax code for politicians and special interests to tinker with

Like the software industry, rich art collectors, the horse racing industry (only reason Emerald Downs is still in business).

2. No more social engineering through the tax code

How else will they get us out of our cars?

3. Eliminates an entire multi billion dollar industry dedicated to tax preparation

Most of whom are Republicans and bribe, erm, donate, accordingly.

Feel free to add your own...

4. Corporations that presently pay little or no tax would have to pay. We can't have that now, can we?

Posted by: Critical THINKER on April 20, 2006 08:41 PM
41. And I'm especially upset when pork earmarks in the US budget go to pet projects in the districts of politicians such as the Bridge to Nowhere in Alaska.

Yeah, the one to some property so that Ted Stevens' family could sell it?

Posted by: Critical THINKER on April 20, 2006 08:44 PM
42. Prior to WWII taxes were paid annually in January of the new year. Withholding did not exist. Tax Withholding came about to solve the cash requirements of WWII. The Feds were ecstatic by the amounts collected by the withholding scheme. So much so, that withholding continued after WWII. Tax filing was moved to April 15th. When I started processing payrolls in the early 60's FICA was about 2.5% (half paid by the employer) 1.25% was a small amount compared to the 15% or so currently paid. Medicare and other withholding taxes were added later. Withholding provides a vehicle for collection of all manner of taxes appeasing the most ardent liberal in their efforts to redistribute the wealth. I doubt that Americans would support such takings if they wrote a check once a year. At one time all interest paid was deducted as an expense. As it should be, because one person's interest is another's income which is taxed. Today, only mortgage interest is allowed as a deduction.Which in effect results in double taxation on any other interest not allowed as a deduction. The 17,000 pages making up the Tax Code are filled with all sort of schemes resulting designed to confuse, and obfuscate the results. Maximizing taxes.

Liberals AKA Democrats support redistribution of the wealth. What the Republicans support is not clear.

Posted by: Snuffy on April 21, 2006 09:32 AM
43. Liberals AKA Democrats support redistribution of the wealth. What the Republicans support is not clear.

Republicans support redistribution of wealth . . . to Halliburton, to Boeing, to Wal-Mart, to General Dynamics, and to all manner of other corporations that survive on the federal tit. Hell, they've redistributed how many billions to fund Bush's Iraq fetish?

Posted by: Critical THINKER on April 21, 2006 10:10 AM
Post a comment
Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember info?