September 07, 2004
Unsound Transit

From the latest news about the taxpayer-financed ongoing exhibit of surrealist performance art commonly known as "Sound Transit": Agency planners are now working feverishly to extend to SeaTac airport the light-rail line that would otherwise dead-end in the middle of the Tukwila wilderness.

Here are a few highlights from the news article:

* The projected ride time from Westlake Center to the airport station would be 33 minutes. [As a point of comparison, Yahoo! Maps estimates that a similar journey by, say, taxicab, would be 22 minutes]

* The pedestrian walk between the airport station and the terminal will be 1,100 feet, or almost a quarter of a mile. [As a point of comparison, an alternative mode of transportation, say, a taxicab, would stop right in front of the terminal]

* The Soundies are assuming that many of the airport rail passengers would be willing to leave their luggage in one train car while riding in a different car, even though surveys of airport rail travelers in other cities show that most passengers are reluctant to be separated from their luggage.

* The millions and billions that would be spent on construction of brand new rail and facilities would serve only 2% of airport travelers. This figure is based on Sound Transit's own [read: unrealistically optimistic] ridership projections.

* Many of the projected riders are assumed to be business travelers staying downtown [read: people who have the expense budget to pay for a cab ride and who would value the relative convenience, shorter travel time, shorter walking and security of knowing where their luggage is, that taxicabs offer but light rail does not].

Posted by Stefan Sharkansky at September 07, 2004 01:21 PM | Email This
Comments
1. For the life of me, I cannot understand why billions are being spent on a mass-transit system and the blasted thing stops a mile and a half from the airport. Why even build the damn thing?

Posted by: jimg on September 7, 2004 04:02 PM
2. Okay, this is where I get into trouble because I'm all the way up in Skagit County but I think Sound Transit is a boondoggle and Ron Sims is running to get unSound Transit more money. Marsha, Stefan, anybody - tell me if I'm wrong?

(P.S. According to Justice Phil Talmadge's press release as a gubernatorial candidate (now out of the race) last autumn, Sims is continnuing to tax the amount I-747 in 2002 repealed.)

Posted by: Josef on September 7, 2004 04:47 PM
3. jimg, because it was never intended to be a transportation system. It was intended to be a jobs program. 5,000 jobs to run a stretch of rail this long is asinine.

And the _second_ piece is the kicker - if they ever succeed in pushing through the second piece of light rail, it will make this one look positively cheap. (It will have to tunnel Capitol Hill.)

This is the reason I personally support the Monorail folks. Yes, it will be expensive also, no it isn't in the _best_ route (the one ST already has). But proof that a transit system can clear the canal for a fraction of the price of ST and run with a net push on operating cost... That had better be the stake to prevent any further pieces of light rail, ever.

Posted by: Al on September 7, 2004 05:38 PM
4. There's no way I would take a train to or from the airport and be separated from my luggage.

I've used the Red Line in Portland to and from the airport a couple times and it was OK, though my friend lives only a couple blocks away from a station.

Posted by: Adam V. on September 7, 2004 06:50 PM
5. Are these people insane? Well, yes, but that's not my point. I thought it was supposed to be a major security issue if one is separated from one's luggage because it gives your random terrorist an opportunity to put something in it. So once you get to the airport and walk a quarter mile with luggage in tow, you are supposed to open all your luggage and make sure that only your stuff is in your luggage. Yes, that will absolutely persuade me to use the silly train.

Posted by: Carol on September 8, 2004 04:49 AM
Post a comment
Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember info?